Menus
Our Dining Room and banquets are now open, Monday thru Saturday 6am-9pm and Sunday 7am-8pm
We are also open for Pick-up and Delivery, Catering and Deli Counter 7 days a week 8-8
We Deliver North to Bluemound, South to Ryan Road, West to Calhoun, and East to the Lake. Call 414-321-4400 to order! online ordering coming soon.
You can also order anything by the pound to take home! Order freshly sliced meats, cheeses, or entrees!
- Brunch
- For the Sweet Tooth
- Sides and Extras
- Omeletts
- Skillets
- Pizza
- Fresh Eggs
- Combos
- Breakfast Sandwiches
- Sharables
- Sandwiches
- Wraps and Paninis
- Burgers
- Pasta & Stir Fry
- Steaks, Chops and BBQ
- Seafood
- Soup & Salad
- Dinners
- Bulk Item Menu
- Papa Luigi's Half-Pan/Full-Pan Catering Menu
- Everyday Catering
- Holiday Menu
- Picnic Menu
- Wedding and Special Events
Brunch
Add a Side of Thick Cut Bacon - $5-
Meyer's Homestyle Corned Beef Hash
slow roasted (for 12 hours) corned beef, onion, fried potatoes, all sautéed, two eggs your way on top, choice of toast
$10.50
-
Granny Smith Apple Pancakes
apple infused pancakes, topped with more apples, house made apple syrup, whipped honey butter
$8
-
Cherry Cobbler Pancakes
topped with sweet cherry sauce, crunchy granola, whipped cream
$9
-
Strawberry Cheesecake French Toast
filled, cheesecake filling, strawberry topping, whipped cream
$9
-
Philly Benedict
english muffin, shaved prime rib, sautéed onions, green peppers, poached eggs, creamy cheese sauce, side of hash browns
$9
-
Oatmeal and Raisin Cookie Waffle
oatmeal infused waffle, raisins, brown sugar, whipped honey butter
$8
-
Salmon Benedict
$13
-
Tory’s Special
Strips of tenderloin, cooked with diced potatoes, onions, spinach and mushrooms, then topped with feta cheese, served with three over easy eggs and choice of toast
$13
-
Granny Smith Apple Pancakes
Homemade batter mixed with seasoned apples, topped with chopped cinnamon spiced apples, served with honey infused whipped butter and apple fusion syrup
$10
-
Belgian Oatmeal & Raisin Waffle
Homemade waffle batter mixed with oatmeal, raisins, and brown sugar, served with freshly whipped honey butter
$8.80
-
Double Chocolate Belgian Waffle
Homemade brownie batter, topped with whipped cream
$10
Add a scoop of ice cream $1.50
-
Red Velvet Pancakes
Three pancakes made just like the cake! Layered with homemade cream cheese frosting
$10
-
Belgian Waffle
Served until 11 am weekdays and 12 pm on weekends
$6.05
Add chocolate chips $1
-
Texas French Toast
Two slices of thick cut french toast
$5.50
-
French Toast
Three pieces of french toast with your choice of white or whole wheat bread
$5.50
Raisin bread $0.20
-
Monte Cristo French Toast
Sliced turkey, ham, and swiss cheese, stacked between 2 thick cut French toast slices, and dusted with powdered sugar
$8.25
-
Cream Cheese Filled Crepes
$6.60
-
3 Stacked Pancakes
$5.50
Add homemade pecan butter $1
-
Chocolate Chip Pancakes
$6
-
Blueberry Pancakes
$7.15
-
Fruit Parfait
Vanilla yogurt topped with, granola, blueberries, and strawberries, served with a homemade corn muffin and honey butter
$6
-
Toasty Oatmeal Bake
Freshly rolled oats with dried cranberries and spiced apples, then baked until golden brown, and topped with a vanilla cream sauce
$5
-
Fruit Plate
Assorted seasonal fruit
$4.25
-
Biscuit & Gravy
$4.40
-
English muffin
$2.25
-
Hash Browns
$2
-
Sausage, Bacon, or Ham
$2.50
-
Croissant
$2.25
-
Hard Roll
$2
-
Grilled Hard Roll
$2.25
-
Hot Oatmeal with Milk
$2.50
-
Add Raisins
$0.20
-
Toast
$2
-
White, Wheat, or Rye Raisin Toast
$2.25
Served with Your Choice of Hash Browns or Fruit, Toast or Hard Roll | Add Cheese +1
-
Standard
Cheese or mushroom
$7.15
-
Meat
Sausage, bacon, or ham
$8.25
-
Denver
Ham, green peppers, and onions
$8.80
-
Seafood
Shrimp, scallops, crab meat, mushrooms, and mozzarella cheese, served with a dill cream sauce
$10.45
-
Mediterranean
Spinach and feta cheese
$8.80
-
Vegetarian
Broccoli, spinach, peppers, asparagus, tomatoes, onions and slices of portabella mushrooms
$8.25
-
California
Turkey, spinach, tomatoes, and swiss cheese, topped with avocado
$9.90
-
Enchilada
Bell peppers, onions, and your choice of cheese, topped with enchilada sauce, shredded lettuce, and tomatoes
$7.70
Add steak $3
-
Corned Beef & Swiss
Fresh chopped corned beef and melted swiss cheese folded in an omelet
$10
Served with Your Choice of Toast or Hard Roll | All Skillets Are Served Over American Fries.
-
Country Chicken
Southern fried chicken breast with onions and peppers, topped with two eggs your way and smothered in homemade sausage gravy
$9.90
-
House
Chopped ham with onions, peppers, mushrooms, tomatoes, topped with two eggs your way and a cheese blend.
$9.35
-
Steak
6 oz. char-grilled Angus flat iron steak with sautéed mushrooms and onions, topped with two eggs your way and a melted cheese blend
$12.65
-
Fajita Chicken
Char-grilled chicken breast with onions, peppers, and mushrooms, topped with a cheese blend, slices of avocado, salsa and sour cream
$10.45
-
Farm House
Sliced portabella mushrooms, chopped asparagus, tomatoes, peppers, and broccoli, topped with two eggs your way with a cheese blend
$9.35
-
Badger Land
Smoked beef sausage with onions and bell peppers, topped with two eggs your way and a cheese blend
$9.90
-
Meat Lovers
Bacon, ham, sausage, onions, and bell peppers, topped with two eggs your way and a cheese blend
$10.45
Papa’s Original THIN-N-CRISPY PIZZA
$11.45-
10” Gluten-Free Cheese Pizza
$11.45
-
Cheese
12” $12.60
-
Hand Tossed Crust
12” $1.25
-
Thick Crust
12” $1.50
-
Topping Price (each)
12” $1.25
-
Extra Sauce
12” $1.25
-
Extra Cheese
12” $1.60
-
Toppings
Sausage, Pepperoni, Mushrooms, Black Olives, Onions, Green Peppers, Tomatoes, Broccoli, Jalapenos, Green Olives, Canadian Bacon, Pineapple, Pepperoncini, Anchovies, Bacon, Ground Beef, Shrimp, Chicken, Spinach
Specialty Pizza
-
Papa’s Veggie Pizza
Cheese, Mushrooms, Onions, Green Peppers and Black Olives
12" $15.50
Papa’s Special
-
Cheese, Sausage, Mushrooms and Onions
12" $15.50
12”- 20.00
-
Papa’s Deluxe
Cheese, Sausage, Mushrooms, Green Peppers, Pepperoni, Black Olives and Onions
-
Chicken Alfredo Pizza
Alfredo Sauce, Mozzarella Cheese and tender chunks of Chicken Breast
-
Hawaiian Pizza
Papa’s Famous Pizza Sauce topped with Mozzarella Cheese, Fresh Pineapple and Canadian Bacon
-
Meat Lover’s Pizza
Pepperoni, Sausage, Ground Beef and Canadian Bacon
-
Bigga Macka
1000 Island Dressing, Ground Beef, Lettuce, Diced Pickles, Diced Onions with a blend of American and Mozzarella Cheese
-
Sicilian Pizza
Based with Olive Oil, topped with Mozzarella Cheese, Sausage and Papa’s Secret Spices
-
Bacon Chicken Ranch
Ranch Dressing, Diced Grilled Chicken, Crispy Bacon Bits, Diced Red Onions and Mozzarella Cheese
-
Bbq Chicken Pizza
Sweet BBQ Sauce, topped with Mozzarella Cheese and tender chunks of Chicken Breast
-
Chicken Parmigiana
Papa’s Famous Pizza Sauce topped with Mozzarella Cheese, Breaded Chicken and sprinkled with Imported Parmesan Cheese
-
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Papa’s Hand Tossed Dough topped with Frankie’s Special Buffalo Sauce, Diced Grilled Chicken Breast, Red Onions, Mozzarella Cheese and sprinkled with Crushed Red Pepper
-
Margherita Pizza
Fresh mozzarella, with sliced whole tomatoes, and fresh basil
-
Champagne Pizza
Topped with a champagne sauce, breaded diced chicken and Italian cheeses
Served with 2 Eggs Your Way, Toast, and Your Choice of Hash Browns or Fruit Unless Noted | Upgrade to Thick Cut Bacon for 1.75 Anywhere Bacon, Sausage or Ham Is Offered.
-
Just Eggs
$5.50
-
Sausage, Bacon, or Ham
$7.70
-
Sunshine Scramble
Peppers onions, and tomatoes
$6.60
-
1/2 Lb. Chopped Sirloin
$9.90
-
Corned Beef Hash
$8.25
-
6 Oz Char Grilled Chicken Breast
$8.25
-
6 Oz Flat Iron Steak
-
Usingers Smoked Sausage
$8.25
-
Biscuits & Gravy “no Toast”
$7.70
-
Country Fried Chicken
$9.35
Upgrade to Ham for .75 or Thick Cut Bacon for 1.75
-
Belgian Combo
1/2 Belgian waffle, two eggs your way, and your choice of bacon or sausage links
$8.80
-
Country Combo
homemade biscuits and gravy, two eggs your way, and your choice of bacon or sausage links
$8.80
-
Little Chuck Wagon
two slices of fluffy French toast or pancakes, two eggs your way, and your choice of bacon or sausage links
$8.80
-
Texas Two Step
two slices of thick cut Texas French toast with two eggs cooked your way, served with a side of bacon or sausage links
$8.80
Breakfast Sandwiches
Served with a choice of Italian pasta salad, homemade potato chips, potato salad, coleslaw or French fries. | Substitute a gluten-free bun $1, add a cup of soup for only 79 cents.
-
Denver
Diced ham, scrambled eggs, onions, and peppers, served on your choice of toast
$8.80
Add cheese $1
-
Croissant
Scrambled eggs with your choice of meat and cheese
$7.15
-
BREAKFAST MELT
Sliced Ham, scrambled eggs, and melted cheddar cheese on grilled rye bread
$7.15
-
Turkey Florentine Wrap
Turkey, scrambled eggs, spinach, mushrooms, diced tomatoes, and Swiss cheese, served in a flour tortilla
$8.25
-
Loaded Breakfast Burrito
Ham, sausage, scrambled eggs, mushrooms, peppers, and a cheddar cheese blend, wrapped in a flour tortilla and drizzled with cheese sauce
$9.35
-
Breakfast Quesadilla
Sausage, scrambled eggs, peppers, onions, and a cheddar cheese blend, wrapped in a flour tortilla, served with a side of salsa and sour cream
-
Country Chicken Benedict
Fried chicken with spinach, tomatoes, and poached eggs, smothered in cheese sauce, served on top of an English muffin with a side of hash browns
-
House Egg’s Benedict
House sliced ham, topped with poached eggs and your choice of cheese sauce or signature hollandaise sauce, served on top of an English muffin with a side of hash browns.
$7.75
Sharables
-
Haystacks
onion, thin sliced, deep fried, piled high
$8.50
-
German Soft Pretzels
3 jumbo soft pretzels, beer cheese, Dusseldorf mustard
$9
-
Seafood Stuffed Mushrooms
mushroom caps, filled w/ a savory crab, shrimp and cheese stuffing, baked
$9
-
Buffalo Wings
10 jumbo wings, choose naked, bbq or buffalo, garlic sesame or mango habanero, choice of ranch or bleu cheese
$10
-
Macho Nachos
diced tomato, onion, pepper, black olives, tomato, jalapeños, cheese blend, sour cream and salsa
$10
Add chicken $2
Add steak $4
-
Cheese Quesadilla
cheddar jack, onion, tomato, pepper, flour tortilla, sour cream and salsa
$7
Add chicken $2
Add steak $3
-
Chicken Tenders
choice of sauce
$8
-
Combination Platter
chicken tenders, mozzarella sticks, haystacks
$13
-
Breaded Mushrooms
lightly breaded, fried
$8
-
Breaded Cauliflower
lightly battered, fried
$8
-
Mac and Cheese Bites
tender pasta and cheese, battered, fried
$8
-
Jalapeño Poppers
choose cheddar or cream cheese
$8
-
Mozzarella Marinara
deep fried, marinara
$8.50
-
Sicilian Fried Eggplant
Featuring Papa Luigi’s! Voted #1 in Southeast Wisconsin! | handmade, deep fried, lemon wedges, marinara
$9
-
Mama Maria’s Garlic Bread
Buttery, marinara
$6
-
Seafood Empanadas
3 mini empanadas made with a cream cheese, blend of fresh blue crab meat, shrimp, scallops, scallions, and peppers. Think crab ragoon!
$12
-
Maryland Crab Cakes
Two Maryland lump crab cakes, pan-seared and served with a sweet Asian slaw and a homemade remoulade sauce
$15
-
Bbq Pork Sliders (3)
Pork shoulder slowly cooked overnight, pulled apart and tossed in our homemade barbeque sauce, topped with Asian slaw and seved on a pretzel bun
$11
-
Reuben Rolls
A combination of chopped corned beef, kraut and swiss wrapped in a crispy wonton. Served with 1000 island for dipping
$9
Served with Your Choice of Italian Pasta Salad, Homemade Potato Chips, Potato Salad, Coleslaw, or French Fries | Substitute Bun for Gluten-Free Bun +$1
-
Cranberry Turkey Focaccia
Sliced roasted turkey, bacon, lettuce, tomato, melted Swiss cheese, and cranberry relish served on toasted focaccia bread
$9
-
Steak Sandwich
6 oz flat iron steak broiled and topped with sautéed mushrooms and onions, topped with Swiss cheese, served on a grilled bun.
$12.50
-
Fish Filet
White roughy, lightly breaded and fried, served with lettuce, tomato, and homemade tartar sauce
$9
-
Salad on A Croissant
Your choice of homemade tuna or chicken salad, served with lettuce and tomato served on a flakey croissant
$9
Add cheese $1
-
Bourbon Beef
Slow cooked shaved prime Angus, topped with a homemade bourbon glaze, melted Swiss cheese, and crispy haystack onions, served on a grilled bun
$11.25
-
Meat Loaf Dinner
Famous thick cut meat loaf topped with mashed potatoes, crispy onion rings, and a rich rosemary mushroom gravy with carrots and peas, served on a grilled bun,
$10
-
Portabella
Grilled portabella cap topped with red onions, tomatoes, cucumbers, spinach, roasted red peppers, and pesto cream cheese, served on grilled focaccia bread
$9
-
Reuben
Slow roasted, pickled corned beef brisket, topped with swiss cheese, homemade sauerkraut, and 1000 island dressing
$11
-
Meatball
Papa Luigi’s famous homemade meatballs, topped with mozzarella cheese and marinara sauce, served on Italian bread
$11.25
-
Pizza Burger
Papa Luigi’s Favorite! grilled Italian sausage patty topped with melted mozzarella, parmesan cheese, and marinara, served on Italian bread
$11.25
Additional toppings: mushrooms, onions, pepperoni, black olives, and green peppers $1
-
Philly Cheesesteak
Thin shaved roast beef, topped with sautéed onions, peppers, and melted cheddar cheese, served on a grilled French bun
$10
-
Chicken Parm Sandwich
Breaded chicken breast, topped with melted mozzarella, parmesan cheese, and Papa Luigi’s famous marinara, served on Italian bread
$11.50
-
Hot Beef or Turkey Sandwich
Choice of bread
$10.50
-
Stacked Ham or Turkey Sandwich
Choice of bread
$10.50
-
BLT Club
Choice of bread
$9.50
-
Turkey BLT Club
Choice of bread
$10
-
Veal Parm Sandwich
Hand trimmed and sliced tender veal, breaded in Italian seasonings and imported cheeses, topped with marinara and mozzarella
$13
Wraps and Panini’s
Served with a choice of Italian pasta salad, homemade potato chips, potato salad, coleslaw or French fries. Substitute a gluten-free bun $1-
Buffalo Chicken Wrap
crispy fried chicken breast, spicy wing sauce, lettuce, tomato, crumbled bleu cheese, ranch dressing
$9.50
-
California Club Wrap
grilled chicken breast, bacon, lettuce, tomato, avocado, crumbled bleu cheese, French dressing
$10.45
-
Santa Fe Chicken Wrap
crispy fried chicken breast, lettuce, tomato, onion, black olives, cheddar jack cheese, cilantro lime sour cream
$10
-
Chicken Crunch Wrap
crisp fried chicken, ham, Swiss, ranch dressing, lettuce, tomato, flour tortilla
$10
-
Mediterranean Chicken Wrap
chargrilled chicken breast, asparagus, lettuce, tomato, cucumber, feta, roasted red pepper aioli, flour tortilla
$10
-
Chicken Ranch Wrap
grilled chicken breast,lettuce, red onion, jalapeño, tomato, cheddar, ranch
$8.50
-
Four Cheese Panini
cheddar, Monterey jack, Swiss, mozzarella, lettuce, bacon, tomato, grilled, side of roasted red pepper aioli
$10
-
Turkey Bacon Cheddar Ranch Panini
turkey, lettuce, tomato, bacon, cheddar, ranch dressing, grilled
$11
-
Shrimp & Pepper Jack Panini
grilled gulf shrimp, pepper jack, lettuce, tomato, red onion. side of roasted red pepper aioli
$12
Burgers
Served with your choice of Italian pasta salad, homemade potato chips, coleslaw, potato salad or French fries. Substitute a chicken breast or portabella mushroom for any burger $1 (excludes triple decker & Bacon Bratzel). All burgers are available gluten-free served without a bun or with a gluten-free bun $1-
Angus Burger
beef patty, grilled your way
1/3 lb $7.75
1/2 lb $8.25
-
Wisco
American, Swiss
1/3 lb $8.75
1/2 lb $9.75
-
Patty Melt
sautéed onion, Swiss, grilled rye
1/3 lb $8.75
1/2 lb $9.75
-
Hangover Burger
bacon, cheddar, sunny side up egg
1/3 lb $9.75
1/2 lb $10.75
-
BBQ Bacon Burger
bacon, BBQ sauce, cheddar, haystacks
1/3 lb $9.75
1/2 lb $10.75
-
California Cheeseburger
bacon, avocado, cheddar, ranch dressing
1/3 lb $9.75
1/2 lb $10.75
-
Mushroom & Swiss
sautéed mushroomz, Swiss
1/3 lb $9.75
1/2 lb $10.75
-
Triple Decker Burger
This is the Big Boy Burger! | Two 1/3 lb patties, bacon, American, Swiss, sautéed mushrooms, onion
$13.25
-
Bacon Bratzel Burger
1/3lb burger, Klements bratwurst patty, bacon, sautéed onions, cheddar, pretzel bun
$13.25
-
Black and Bleu
Cajun seasoning, bacon, bleu cheese crumbles
1/3 lb $9
1/2 lb $10
Pasta & Stir Fry
-
Featuring Papa Luigi’s Award Winning Fettuccine Alfredo
$12.50
Add chicken $2
Add shrimp $3
-
Mediterranean Pasta
sautéed chicken, mushrooms, roasted red pepper, zucchini, tomato, angel hair, feta, basil pesto, garlic bread
$11.50
-
Angel Hair Garlic
thin pasta, butter sauce, sautéed
$11.50
Add chicken $2
Add shrimp $3
-
Crab Linguine Alfredo
crab meat, fettucini, garlic toast
$17
-
Sal’s Seafood Sensation
shrimp, lobster, scallops, crabmeat, sautéed, served over a bed of fresh linguini noodles, choice of sauce
$18
-
Spaghetti or Mostaccioli
choose your pasta, marinara, choice of meatballs, meat sauce or Italian sausage link
$12
-
Pasta Primavera
linguini pasta, zucchini, broccoli, carrots, red peppers, garlic butter sauce
$12.50
Add chicken $2
Add shrimp $3
-
Papa Luigi’s Chicken Parmigiana
breaded chicken breast, mozz, papa's signature marinara sauce, bed of linguini
$12.50
-
Lasagna
Featuring Papa Luigi’s Home Made Famous Favorite! | layered, fresh pasta, seasoned ground beef, ricotta, mozz, parm
$14.50
-
Cashew Chicken
sautéed chicken, oriental vegetables, cashews, stir fry sauce, white rice
$11
-
Beef and Broccoli
sautéed, prime sirloin, red pepper, mushrooms, onion, broccoli, tossed, sesame stir fry sauce, over white rice
$12
Steaks, Chops and BBQ
Steaks ordered medium well or well done are not guaranteed to be as tender.-
Rib Eye Steak Dinner
10 oz. Choice Angus rib steak char grilled, topped with steak butter, crispy onion rings
$18
-
BBQ Baby Back Ribs
secret rib rub, slow roasted, BBQ sauce, coleslaw, choice of potato
Half Rack $17
Full Rack $23
-
Bourbon Pork Steak
8oz pork rib eye, char grilled, sautéed onion, mushrooms, house recipe bourbon glaze
$13
-
Flat Iron Steak
6oz, chargrilled, sautéed mushrooms and onion, house recipe steak butter
$15
Seafood
-
Fresh Walleye Pike
choose pan seared, broiled or breaded and fried
$13
-
Chef Dusted Shrimp
9 gulf shrimp breaded and deep fried, house made cocktail sauce
$12
-
Bourbon Salmon Filet
Atlantic salmon filet, baked, house recipe bourbon glaze
$13
-
Citrus Broiled Tilapia
broiled, homemade citrus glaze, mandarin oranges
$11
gluten free
-
Beer Battered Cod
choice of potato, coleslaw, tartar
$13
-
Fried or Baked Cod
choice of potato, coleslaw, tartar
$11.50
-
Papa Luigi’s Skewered Shrimp Scampi
2 shrimp scampi skewers, grilled, over a bed of angel hair pasta sautéed with garlic butter sauce
$14
-
Trout Amandine
fresh 10 oz rainbow trout filet pan seared and topped with butter and toasted almonds
$13.50
Soup & Salad
All salads served with fresh bread except for salads served in a shell, substitute portabella mushroom for $1.5, shrimp $2, steak $3
-
Chicken Caesar
grilled chicken breast, romaine, black olives, tomato, croutons, parmesan, Caesar dressing
$9
-
Chicken BLT
grilled chicken breast, egg, onion, tomato, bacon, black olives, avocado, crumbled bleu cheese
$10
-
Chef
ham, turkey, tomato, egg, onion, pepper, cheese
$9
-
Meyer's Chicken Wedge
iceberg lettuce, grilled chicken breast, applewood smoked bacon, tomato, bleu cheese crumbles, avocado, chopped egg, house made bleu cheese dressing
$9
-
Raspberry Chicken
grilled chicken breast, tomato, red onion, mushrooms, croutons, mandarin oranges, parmesan,raspberry walnut vinaigrette
$9.99
-
Fiesta Chicken
crispy fried chicken breast, onion, pepper, tomato, cheddar jack cheese, black olives, crispy tortilla shell, salsa and sour cream
$10
-
Salmon Chop
fresh salmon pieces, tomato, black olives, chopped bacon, avocado, corn, mushrooms, crumbled bleu cheese, boiled egg, tossed with honey dijon vinaigrette
$11
-
Hot Bacon Cobb
grilled chicken breast, spinach, onion, tomato, mushroom, boiled egg, Swiss, house made hot bacon dressing
$10
-
Strawberry Gorgonzola Chicken
grilled chicken breast, red onion, tomato, lettuce, sliced strawberries, gorgonzola, homemade strawberry vinaigrette
$9.50
-
Side Caesar or Spinach Salad
$5
-
Side Salad
$4
-
Soup of the Day
Cup $3.25
Bowl $4.25
-
French Onion Soup
Served in a crock, topped with melted Swiss cheese
$5
-
Soup and Salad
A bowl of soup and a side salad with your choice of dressing and Italian bread
$7
-
Like our Soup? Take home a quart!
$7.50
Dinners
Served with choice of potato and fresh vegetable unless otherwise noted below.-
Our Famous Broasted Chicken
The best in town! Tender, juicy and delicious…with coleslaw and choice of potato
1/4 Chicken $9
1/2 Chicken $10.50
All white or all dark meat $2
-
Rosemary Mushroom Pork
lightly breaded pork cutlets, pan fried, topped w/ rosemary mushroom gravy
$10.50
-
German Sauerbraten
marinated beef, sweet and sour ginger snap gravy, braised red cabbage, homemade potato dumpling
$13
-
German Wurstchen Platter
Usingers knackwurst and bratwurst, bed of house made sauerkraut, mashed potatoes, Dusseldorf mustard
$11
gluten free
-
Monterey Chicken Plate
char grilled chicken breast, sautéed mushrooms, onion, broccoli, ranch sauce, mozzarella
$11
gluten free
-
Citrus Grilled Chicken
char grilled chicken breast, sweet and tangy citrus glaze, topped with mandarin oranges
$10.50
gluten free
-
Rustic Country Meat Loaf
homemade meat loaf, pan seared, rosemary mushroom gravy, onion rings
$10.50
-
Chicken Tender Basket
French fries, coleslaw
$11.50
-
Beef Pot Roast
slow roasted, hand sliced, super tender, mashed potatoes, gravy, peas, carrots
$12
Let us help cater your next event with our homemade specialties, saving you time and money. Some items require at least 24 hours notice, check with our staff for details. If you are interested in any of our entrees not shown here, they often can be arranged by speaking with the chef.
Entrees
Prices below are based on a 5 lb minimum. Add $2 per pound for orders under 5 lbs-
Roast Beef In Gravy (Dinner/Sandwich slice)
Beef Chuck roast slow roasted in savory gravy
lb $11.99
-
Roast Turkey In Gravy (Dinner/Sandwich slice)
Slow roasted turkey in homemade gravy
lb $8.99
-
BBQ Beef Brisket (Dinner/Sandwich slice)
Smoked and slow roasted beef brisket tossed with our house recipe BBQ sauce
lb $9.99
-
Roast Pork Loin In Gravy (Dinner/Sandwich slice)
lb $7.99
-
Oven Baked Ham (Dinner/Sandwich slice)
lb $7.99
-
Fried Cod
Served with tartar sauce
lb $9.99
-
Fresh Polish Sausage
Served in sauerkraut
lb $8.99
-
Sirloin Tips & Noodles
Braised with mushrooms and onions
lb $10.99
-
Meatballs (BBQ or Marinara)
16 meatballs per pound
lb $7.99
-
Pulled Pork
Smoked and slow roasted pork shoulder
lb $7.99
-
BBQ Ribs
Full rack of ribs smoked, slow roasted and brushed with our house recipe BBQ sauce
lb $12.99
-
Chicken Tenders
Served with choice of BBQ or racnh
lb $7.99
-
Meat Loaf
Topped with savory brown gravy
lb $8.99
Fish Fry
Served with tartar sauce-
8pc Cod
$14.99
-
16pc Cod
$27.99
-
8pc Family Cod
With 1lb coleslaw, 1lb mashed potatoes or French fries
$19.99
-
16pc Family Cod
With 2lbs coleslaw, 2lbs mashed potatoes or French fries
$35.99
-
12pc Cod
$20.99
-
20pc Cod
$33.99
-
12pc Family Cod
With 1lb coleslaw, 1lb mashed potatoes or French fries
$25.99
-
20pc Family Cod
With 2lbs coleslaw, 2lbs mashed potatoes or French fries
$41.99
Our Famous Broasted Chicken
-
8pc Chicken
$11.99
All white chicken $19.99
-
16pc Chicken
$23.99
All white chicken $39.99
-
8pc Family Meal
With 1lb coleslaw and 1lb mashed potatoes or French fries
$16.99
All white chicken $24.99
-
16pc Family Meal
With 2lbs coleslaw and 2lbs mashed potatoes or French fries
$34.99
All white chicken $50.99
-
Broasted Chicken Breasts Only
8pc minimum
/ea $3.75
-
12pc Chicken
$17.99
All white chicken $29.99
-
20pc Chicken
$29.99
All white chicken $49.99
-
12pc Family Meal
With 1lb coleslaw and 1lb mashed potatoes or French fries
$20.99
All white chicken $32.99
-
20pc Family Meal
With 2lbs coleslaw and 2lbs mashed potatoes or French fries
$39.99
All white chicken $59.99
-
Ala Carte Chicken (10-99pcs)
ea $1.75
-
Ala Carte Chicken (Over 100pcs)
ea $1.45
Sides
-
Meyer's Homemade Chili
Our house recipe ground beef chili served nice and hot and topped with cheddar cheese blend.Served with crackers
$4.99
Have a cup for only $3.99
-
French Fries
lb $2.99
-
Mashed Potatoes & Gravy
lb $2.99
-
Tossed Salad
Mixed lettuce with shredded carrot, cabbage, tomatoes, cucumbers and two dressing choices
lb $3.49
-
Potato Salad
lb $2.99
-
Italian Pasta Salad
lb $2.99
-
Bread Dressing
lb $2.99
-
Corn, Green Beans or Carrots
lb $2.99
-
Potato Pancakes(6)
$4
-
Rolls & Butter(12)
$6
Desserts
-
Lemon Berry Cake
Moist lemon cake layered with mascarpone cheese, berries and whipped cream
$32.99
-
Apple Strudel
Cinnamon spiced apples and raisins folded in puff pastry and baked until golden brown
$25.99
-
Whole Plain Cheesecake
$28.99
-
Carrot Cake
Homemade carrot cake layered with cream cheese frosting
$27.99
Starters
-
Fresh Italian Bread
A loaf $4
-
Garlic Bread
Full pan $25
Half pan $15
-
Mama Maria’s
An order $4.50
-
Veggie Tray
Small $40
Large $60
-
Cheese Tray
Small $50
Large $75
-
Fruit Tray
Small $75
Large $85
-
Antipasta Platter
Italian Cheeses, Salami’s, Olives or Artichokes
$85
-
Cocktail Sandwiches
Shaved Ham, Turkey or Beef
A dozen $19
-
Shrimp Cocktail
-
Buffalo Wings
A dozen $15
-
Chicken Tenders
A dozen $14
-
Mozzarella Sticks
A dozen $11
-
Jalapeño Poppers
A dozen $12
Sides & Salads
-
Salad with dressing
Full Pan $65
Half Pan $35
-
Parsley Buttered Red Potatoes
full pan $60
Half pan $35
-
Garlic Green Beans
Fulll pan $60
Half pan $35
-
Garlic Mashed Potatoes
Full pan $90
Half pan $45
-
Shrimp Salad
Full pan $75
Half pan $40
-
Veggie Pasta Salad
Full pan $75
Half pan $40
-
Roman Potato Salad
Full pan $75
Half pan $40
Entrees Section
-
Baked Mostaccioli with cheese
Full pan $75
Half pan $40
-
Baked Mostaccioli with meat
And cheese/ or veggies (California blend of broccoli, cauliflower, carrots, and zucchini)
Full pan $95
Half pan $50
-
Meat or Spinach Lasagna
Full pan $125
Half pan $65
-
Spaghetti with Marinara
Full pan $60
Half pan $35
-
Spaghetti with Meat Sauce
Full pan $85
Half pan $45
-
Meatballs by The Dozen
$30
-
Fettuccini Alfredo
Full pan $100
Half pan $60
-
Chicken Alfredo
Full pan $125
Half pan $75
-
Meat or Cheese Ravioli
Full pan $110
Half pan $60
-
Pasta Primavera with Veggies
Full pan $90
Half pan $50
Add chicken $25
Add shrimp $35
-
Broasted Chicken
Per piece $2.50
-
Baked Chicken
Per piece $2.50
-
Italian Sausage & Peppers
Full pan $120
Half pan $65
-
Eggplant Parmesan
Full pan $125
Half pan $65
-
Italian Beef
Full pan $160
Half pan $85
-
Shrimp Scampi
Market Price
-
Beef Spiedini
Full pan $125
Half pan $70
First Choice Catering is a full-service catering company dedicated to providing you and your guests with the best experience. The Purpora family, owners of Meyers Restaurant and Papa Luigi’s, have been serving the community for over 45 years, known for serving deliciously crafted meals and exceptional service at an affordable price.
First Choice Catering has an extensive menu to accommodate all events, large or small. We have a reputable history in the corporate world offering box lunches, buffet lines, individually packaged meals, and catering to both picnics and holiday parties.
We offer a wide variety of wedding packages to accommodate you on your special day. We are extremely proud of our creative chefs, team, and staff for their outstanding care for our customers. The Purpora family is excited to be apart of your next event and can’t wait to show you why we’re the First Choice.
Breakfast
-
Breakfast Box
Grab and Go! Choice of Bagel with cream cheese or breakfast muffin, fresh cut-up fruit, and yogurt with granola
$9
-
Farmers market Breakfast Casserole
Italian Chicken Sausage, onion, sliced mushrooms shredded hash browns, cheddar cheese, green peppers, tomatoes, and eggs baked till golden brown. Served with fresh fruit, bagels, and muffins
$12.95
-
Baked Oatmeal
Rolled oats with dried cranberries & spiced apples, baked & topped with a vanilla cream sauce served with fresh fruit salad and assorted muffins
$9
-
Spinach and Ham Gruyere Frittata
Delicate baked egg frittata with fresh spinach, black forest ham, and rich Gruyere cheese
$12.50
-
Good Morning
Scrambled Eggs, Bacon, Pork or Turkey Sausage, Potatoes O’ Brian, Bagels, Muffins, and Seasonal Fruit
$11.95
-
Build Your Own Breakfast Burrito
Scrambled eggs, green pepper, tomato, onion, blended cheese, cilantro, and choice of chorizo, sausage, or bacon. Served with Flour tortilla, salsa, fresh fruit, and hashbrowns or Potatoes O’ Brian
$11.50
-
Continental
An assortment of fresh donuts, Danish, bagels, muffins, and seasonal fruit. Served with cream cheese, jam, and butter
$9.95
-
Country Breakfast
Scrambled Eggs, biscuits and sausage gravy, bacon, and seasonal fruit
$11.95
-
Homemade Pancakes
Served with Bacon, Pork, or Turkey Sausage (choice of 2 options per event)
Buttermilk Pancakes $10.50
Chocolate Chip Pancakes $11
Blueberry $11
Granny Smith Apple $11.50
Cherry Cobbler $11.50
Red Velvet $11.50
Cinnamon Roll $11.50
-
Home Style Corned Beef Hash
Served with scrambled eggs, fresh fruit salad, and assorted muffins
$12.95
Appetizer Platters
Small - Serves up to 15 guestsMedium - Serves up to 25 guests
Large - Serves up to 35 guests
-
Smoked Salmon Platter
Norwegian style smoked Atlantic salmon thinly sliced and beautifully displayed with boiled colored baby potatoes, red onion, sliced cucumbers, sliced radish, sliced cherry tomato, hardboiled egg, caper guests, lemon wedges, fresh dill, cream cheese and rye cocktail bread
Small $69.95
Medium $94.95
Large $124.95
-
Street Skewers
An assortment of skewers fashioned off street vendors: beef bulgogi, lemongrass pork, and chicken satay
Small $59.95
Medium $79.95
Large $99.95
-
Vegetarian Platter
An inviting platter of vegetarian bites including: roasted vegetable skewers; mini cucumber, cream cheese, avocado, and sprout wraps; asparagus and caramelized onion tartlets; Caprese skewers – cherry tomato, fresh mozzarella, and fresh basil
Small $59.95
Medium $79.95
Large $99.95
-
Get Pickled and Go Nuts Platter
An enticing display of pickled vegetables, spiced nuts, and Wisconsin cheese curds
Small $64.95
Medium $84.95
Large $104.95
-
Salsa Trio
Your guests will say ‘ole to our homemade guacamole, Pico de Gallo and black bean corn salsa served with seasoned homemade tortilla chips
Small $49.95
Medium $59.95
Large $79.95
-
Chips and Dips
Homemade spinach and sour cream dip, roasted red pepper hummus paired with homemade pita chips, and our famous homemade kettle chips
Small $49.95
Medium $59.95
Large $79.95
-
Vegetable Crudité
Seasonal garden vegetables served with organic dill dip and red pepper hummus
Small $42.95
Medium $59.95
Large $77.95
-
Hummus Trio
Classic, harissa red pepper and basil pesto hummus served with pita bread, pita chips, cucumbers, bell peppers, and grape tomatoes
Small $49.95
Medium $69.95
Large $89.95
-
Fresh Fruit
Fresh seasonal fruit
Small $54.95
Medium $72.95
Large $94.95
-
Wisconsin Cheese Tray
An assortment of Wisconsin cheese selections served with an assortment of crackers, grapes, and candied nuts
Small $53.95
Medium $72.95
Large $90.95
-
Cheese and Sausage Tray
Our Wisconsin cheese offerings served with a variety of local sausages and crackers
Small $69.95
Medium $88.95
Large $107.95
-
Artisan Cheese Platter
An inspiring display of aged cheddar, Havarti, Manchego, and Bleu cheese accompanied with baguette, crackers, dried fruit, nuts, and preserves
Small $81.95
Medium $101.95
Large $121.95
-
Italian Platter
Mini roasted vegetable and fresh pesto skewers; little salami, cherry mozzarella, artichoke, and tomato spikes with an herb dip; lemon and rosemary marinated chicken skewers with olive tapenade dip
Small $69.95
Medium $89.95
Large $107.95
-
Mini Sandwich Platter
An assortment of sandwiches on mini-rolls that includes: curried chicken salad; roasted turkey breast with cranberry mayo; tomato, mozzarella, and basil with balsamic mayo; tender roast beef and cheddar with Dijon mayo
$36 per dozen
-
Mini Wrap Platter
Selection of mini wraps with following fillings; pesto mayo, grilled chicken with spinach; roasted vegetables with mozzarella; bacon, butternut and feta; shaved roast beef with romaine, tomato, and lemon Dijon mayo
$36 per dozen
-
Wraps and Minis
Selection of our most popular artisanal wraps and sandwiches on mini rolls, and assorted wraps
$36 per dozen
Cold Hors d’Oeuvres
-
Smoked Salmon Rye Canape
Goat cheese, thin slices of smoked salmon, shaved radish, and a watercress sprig on top of cocktail rye bread
24 pieces $54.95
-
Prosciutto Wrapped Mozzarella and Basil
Cherry tomato, mozzarella ball, and basil wrapped in prosciutto and drizzled with balsamic glaze
24 pieces $54.95
-
BLT Crostini
Toasted baguette topped with herb mayo, lettuce, tomato, and applewood bacon
24 pieces $42.95
-
Caprese Skewers
Cherry tomatoes, fresh mozzarella ovoline, and basil drizzled with a balsamic reduction
24 pieces $42.95
-
Antipasto Skewers
Provolone, salami, cherry tomato and pepperoncini
24 pieces $44.95
-
Fresh Fruit Kabobs
Cut fresh seasonal fruit on a skewer
24 pieces $38.95
-
Cucumber Canapés
Classic finger sandwich on rye with herbed cream cheese and mayo, fresh cucumber and topped with diced pimento and dill
24 pieces $40.95
-
Prosciutto Wrapped Asparagus
Asparagus spears wrapped in prosciutto drizzled lemon-infused extra virgin olive oil and dusted with aged parmesan cheese
24 pieces $49.95
-
Chicken Avocado Bacon Slider
Pepper jack cheese, avocado spread with cilantro, bacon, grilled chicken breast, tomato, caramelized onion, and a wee bit of hot sauce on a slider bun
24 pieces $69.95
-
Shrimp Cocktail
Jumbo steamed shrimp with classic cocktail sauce and lemon
24 pieces $59.95
-
Ricotta & Black Olive Crostini
With lemon zest and mint. Amazing combination
24 pieces $42.95
-
Bistro Beef Bites
Deli roast beef on snack rye with horseradish cream spread topped with a half grape tomato and sour cream
24 pieces $59.95
-
Tomato Bruschetta
An Italian classic, toasted baguette slices topped with fresh diced, onion, garlic, olive oil, and fresh basil
24 pieces $42.95
-
Deviled Eggs
Classic deviled eggs with horseradish, vinegar, mayo, and smoked paprika
24 pieces $34.95
-
Sriracha Deviled Eggs with Bacon
Live a little!
24 pieces $36.95
Hot Hors d’Oeuvres
-
Angus Cheddar Sliders
Angus slider with cheddar cheese and condiments
24 pieces $79.95
-
Buffalo Chicken Slider
Chicken breast fritter in Buffalo sauce on a mini roll with lettuce and bleu cheese dressing
24 pieces $69.95
-
Mini Street Taco Quesadilla
Shredded chicken, shredded Mexican cheese, jalapeno, pico de gallo, cilantro, red onion, and spices in a grilled flour tortilla. Olé!
24 pieces $49.95
-
Teriyaki Chicken Skewer
Grilled teriyaki marinated chicken breast cubes on a skewer
24 pieces $45.95
-
Grilled Asian Steak Kabob
Cubes of sirloin marinated in a delicious Asian sesame sauce grilled with red onion and pineapple
24 pieces $69.95
-
Mini Meatball Skewer
Beef and pork mini meatballs on a spike with marinara or BBQ sauce
24 pieces $39.95
-
Jalapeno Popper
Our homemade jalapeno pepper stuffed with pineapple and cream cheese, wrapped in bacon and baked. Can you eat just one?
24 pieces $44.95
-
Mini Chicken Cordon Bleu
Mini chicken cordon bleus with Swiss cheese and smoked ham, coated in bread crumbs and baked
24 pieces $48.95
-
Mini Beef Wellington
Beef tenderloin simmered in a savory sauce of wine, mushrooms, and herbs, then wrapped in a flaky French pastry
24 pieces $79.95
-
Spinach Artichoke Cup
Won’t last long! Spinach, artichoke, parmesan cheese, mozzarella cheese, cream cheese, sour cream, and a touch of cayenne mixed and baked in a phyllo cup
24 pieces $55.95
-
Buffalo Wings
Our breaded and deep-fried wings. Choose between buffalo, sesame ginger, or honey soy sauce. Served with celery and bleu cheese dip
24 pieces $49.95
-
Rumaki
Bacon-wrapped chestnuts with soy glaze
24 pieces $39.95
-
Sausage Stuffed Mushroom Caps
Large mushroom caps generously stuffed with a spicy Italian sausage stuffing
24 pieces $49.95
-
Spinach & Cheese Stuffed Mushrooms
Mushroom caps stuffed with feta, spinach, and cream cheese then dusted with bread crumbs
24 pieces $45.95
-
Vegetable Spring Roll
A colorful mixture of Chinese vegetables tossed with soy sauce, sesame oil, and a touch of fresh ginger wrapped in a spring roll wrapper. Served with sweet and sour sauce
24 pieces $39.95
-
Crab Cakes
Full-sized crab cakes topped with lemon mustard and tarragon aioli. Served with remoulade sauce
24 pieces $69.95
-
Meatballs
Cocktail meatballs in your choice of Swedish or our homemade BBQ sauce
24 pieces $34.95
-
Potato Skins
Baked half potato skin filled with avocado, bacon, cheddar and topped with a dollop of sour cream and chopped chives
24 pieces $49.95
-
Mini Quiche
An assortment of three cheese, mushroom, classic French and Florentine
24 pieces $49.95
-
Italian Beef Bites
Thinly sliced Italian beef with mozzarella and hot giardiniera wrapped up in a crispy wonton wrapper served with au jus
24 pieces $39.95
-
Rueben Rolls
Chopped corned beef hand-rolled with swiss cheese and sauerkraut in a crispy wonton wrapper. Served with house-made thousand island dressing
24 pieces $39.95
-
Italian Sausage
With peppers and onions
24 links sliced $59.95
Cold Buffets
Deli Wrap and Sandwich Buffet $13
Your choice of any four of the following along with two sides and our homemade chips-
Roasted Turkey Breast Pesto Sandwich
Swiss Cheese, red onion, pesto, lettuce, and tomato on focaccia bread
-
Loaded Steer
Tender sliced roast beef, creamy horseradish mayo, sliced tomato, cheddar cheese, pickled red onion, and arugula in a whole wheat wrap
-
Turkey Avocado Club Sandwich
Roast Turkey breast, avocado, romaine lettuce, red onion, cucumber applewood smoked bacon on focaccia bread
-
Homemade Chicken or Tuna Salad
-
Chicken Caesar Wrap
Romaine, tomato, grilled chicken breast, Caesar dressing in a tomato basil wrap
-
Ham and Cheese on Rye
Black forest ham, Swiss cheese, lettuce, tomato, and Dijon on rye bread
-
Portabella
Grilled portabella cap topped with red onions, tomatoes, cucumbers, spinach, roasted red peppers, and pesto cream cheese on a focaccia bread
Deli Boards $12
Your Choice of three meats and two cheesesServed with homemade chips, two side salads, assorted rolls and breads, lettuce, tomatoes, red onion, pepperoncini, pickles mustard and mayo
-
Meats:
Roast beef, turkey breast, shaved ham, homemade shaved corned beef, chicken salad, and tuna salad
-
Cheese:
Wisconsin Cheddar, Swiss, Pepper Jack
-
Side Choices:
Potato salad, creamy coleslaw, pasta salad, fresh fruit, Asian slaw, mixed green salad
Box Lunches $11
Includes, one sandwich with chips, one side, pickle, and cookie-
Sandwich Options:
Sliced Ham
Sliced Turkey Breast
Shaved Roast Beef
Chicken Salad
Tuna Salad
-
Side Options:
Potato Salad
Fresh Fruit
Creamy Coleslaw
Asian Slaw
Pasta Salad
Mixed Green Salad
Artisanal Sandwiches & Wraps Box Lunch $13
One premium wrap or sandwich, one side, dill pickle, chips, and a freshly baked cookie-
Little Italy
Ham, Salami, Pepperoni, olive oil, red wine vinegar, oregano, hot peppers, lettuce, tomato, wrapped in a tomato basil wrap served on focaccia bread
-
Portabella
Grilled portabella cap topped with red onions, tomatoes, cucumbers, spinach, roasted red peppers, and pesto cream cheese on a focaccia bread
-
Chicken or Tuna Salad Croissants
-
Loaded Steer
Tender sliced roast beef, creamy horseradish mayo, sliced tomato, cheddar cheese, pickled red onion, and arugula in a whole wheat wrap
-
Chicken Caesar Wrap
Romaine, tomato, grilled chicken breast, Caesar dressing in a tomato basil wrap
-
Turkey Avocado Club Sandwich
Roast turkey breast, avocado, romaine lettuce, red onion, cucumber applewood smoked bacon served on focaccia bread
Salad Boxes
Include Italian bread and butter and a cookie-
Chicken Caesar
Grilled chicken breast on a bed of romaine lettuce, tossed with black olives, diced tomatoes, shredded parmesan cheese, croutons, served with homemade Caesar dressing
$10
-
Chicken BLT Salad
Grilled chicken breast on a bed of crisp iceberg lettuce, tossed bacon, hard-boiled eggs, onions, tomatoes, black olives, and avocado, served with crumbled bleu cheese and choice of dressing
$11
-
Chef Salad
Sliced ham and turkey on a bed of crisp iceberg lettuce, tossed with hard-boiled eggs, onions, tomatoes, peppers, and cheese
$12
-
Fiesta Chicken
Crispy fried chicken breast on a bed of fresh greens with onion, pepper, tomato, shredded cheddar jack cheese blend, and black olives served in a crispy tortilla shell, with salsa and sour cream
$12
-
Hot Bacon Cobb
Grilled chicken breast on a bed of fresh baby spinach with red onion, tomato, mushroom, boiled egg, swiss cheese, and our house-made hot bacon dressing
$12
-
Harvest Cobb
Chargrilled chicken breast over romaine with chopped eggs, dried cranberries, fresh apples, blue cheese crumbles, applewood smoked bacon, pecans, and peas and finished with a homemade poppy seed vinaigrette
$12
-
Waldorf
Chargrilled chicken breast tossed with crispy green apples, grapes, roasted walnuts, and celery served with a homemade Waldorf dressing
$12
-
Apple Pecan Arugula
Chargrilled chicken breast tossed with dried cranberries, roasted pecans, gala apples, feta cheese, and arugula, finished with a homemade lemon vinaigrette
$12
-
Summer Berry Salad
Grilled chicken breast atop crispy lettuce, tomatoes, blueberries, strawberries, raspberries, blackberries, toasted almonds, mandarin oranges, cucumbers, feta cheese, and a homemade raspberry walnut vinaigrette
$12
-
House Salad
$9.25
Hot Buffets
Grand Buffet
All entrées include your choice of our house salad or Caesar salad and fresh dinner rollsOne entrée, one starch, one vegetable from our tasty options below | $16
Two entrées, a vegetable, and two sides | $18
-
Lasagna
Featuring Papa Luigi’s Homemade Favorite! Fresh pasta layered with seasoned ground beef, ricotta, mozzarella, and parmesan cheese, topped with Papa Luigi’s signature marinara
-
Papa Luigi’s Fettuccine Chicken Alfredo
-
Chicken Piccata
Tender chicken breast, breaded and sautéed in white wine, lemon butter caper enhanced sauce
-
Classic Beef Stroganoff
Tender beef tips sautéed with mushrooms and onions and simmered in a rich sour cream and burgundy sauce. Served with egg noodles
-
Slow Cooked Pot Roast
Boneless sliced short rib slow-cooked with peas, carrots, onions, and mashed potatoes, topped with a rich homemade gravy
-
Beef Tips Bourguignonne
Tender tips of beef, seared and served in a red wine and demi-glaze sauce
-
Eggplant Parmesan
Thinly sliced eggplant, breaded in egg wash and seasoned breadcrumbs, fried then layered with Papa Luigi’s marinara, mozzarella, and baked
-
Mom’s Meatloaf
Pan-seared homemade meatloaf, topped with homemade rosemary mushroom gravy
-
Roast Turkey dinner
Slow-roasted turkey with sage and herbs
-
Roasted Chicken
Skin-on chicken pieces rubbed with olive oil and spices, then baked with fresh rosemary until golden brown
-
Honey Baked Ham
Smoked pit ham and served with a pineapple glaze
-
Herb Crusted Pork Loin
Thyme and rosemary crusted loin
-
Starches
Rice pilaf, Classic garlic mashed potatoes, Baked potato with sour cream & butter, Oven-roasted rosemary potatoes, Mac n’ cheese, Butter garlic pasta
-
Vegetables
Honey glazed carrots, Green beans Amandine, Garlic parmesan roasted broccoli, Tuscan sautéed vegetables – yellow squash, zucchini, carrots, green beans, red pepper, Whole kernel corn, basil and red pepper medley, Steamed California vegetables – broccoli, cauliflower, and carrots
Executive Buffet
All entrées include your choice of our house salad or Caesar salad and fresh dinner rollsOne entrée, one starch, one vegetable from our tasty options below | $18
Two entrées, a vegetable, and two sides | $20
-
Slow Roasted Beef Brisket
Moist and tender slow-roasted brisket served in a horseradish thyme cream sauce
-
Spinach and Artichoke Stuffed Chicken Breast
Baked all-natural chicken breast stuffed with spinach, artichoke, cream cheese, mozzarella, and herbs
-
Cherry Stuffed Pork Loin
Slow-roasted pork loin stuffed with cherries, onion, celery, carrot, parsley, sage, rosemary, and croutons. Served with a rosemary gravy
-
Braised Cabernet Short Ribs
Short ribs braised and slow-cooked for 5 hours until fork-tender
Add $2
-
Chicken Marsala
Pan-fried chicken breast in a dry marsala wine sauce with mushrooms & onions
-
Chicken Cordon Bleu
Large boneless chicken breast stuffed with smoked ham and swiss cheese and then lightly breaded and baked
-
Bourbon Glazed Salmon
Atlantic salmon filet, brushed with homemade Bourbon glaze, then baked
-
Butternut Squash Ravioli
In a sage brown butter sauce
-
Goat Cheese Ravioli
Fluffy pillows of pasta filled with creamy goat cheese in a rich champagne sauce
-
Parmesan Crusted Chicken
Boneless skinless chicken breast topped with a parmesan cream sauce, toasted bread crumbs, and broiled
-
Starches
Roasted cauliflower puree with parmesan and crispy onions Long grain wild rice, Whipped potatoes with parmesan or gorgonzola Roasted root vegetables, Bacon quinoa with almonds and herbs Double baked potato, Fingerling roasted potatoes, Mushroom risotto
-
Vegetables
Garlic parmesan roasted broccoli, Peas with onion, mushrooms and tarragon Sautéed zucchini and squash with garlic and parmesan Braised Brussels sprouts in cider and bacon Parisian carrots, Pan seared asparagus Green beans with cherries and citrus glaze ...more Hot Buets
Italian Buffet $18
Includes 2 entrees, one starch, a salad and bread & butter-
Pasta Entrées
Pasta with Meatballs
Fettuccini Alfredo - Choose Chicken or Shrimp
Lasagna - Choose Meat or Spinach
Cheese or Beef Tortellini
Lasagna Rolls - Choose 4 Cheese, Italian Sausage or Spinach
Pasta Primavera
Italian Macaroni & Cheese
Crab Linguine Alfredo
Sal’s Seafood Sensation - Linguini pasta with sautéed shrimp, lobster, scallops, crab meat & garlic butter
-
Sausage
Italian Sausage & Peppers
Sausage Cacciatore
-
Veal
Veal Piccata + $2
Veal Parmigiana + $3
-
Chicken
Chicken Parmigiana
Baked Chicken Cacciatore
Oven Roasted Chicken
Parmesan Crusted Chicken
Chicken Caprese
Chicken Marsala
Chicken Piccata
-
Beef
Hand Rolled Spiedini
Sliced Italian Beef
-
Beef Upgrades
+ $3
Sicilian Steak
Steak Marsala
Braised Short Rib
Short Rib Ragu
-
Choice 2 Potatoes or 2 Pastas
Pasta with Marinara, Garlic Butter, Alfredo or Champagne Sauce
Roasted Fingerling Potatoes
Roasted Baby Reds
Parsley Boiled Potatoes
Garlic Mashed Potatoes
Sicilian Potato Salad
Themed Packages
American Comfort Food $18
Two entrées served with a garden salad, sage bread dressing, mashed potatoes and gravy, a vegetable and choice of cold side-
Poultry
Roasted Turkey Breast
Roasted Chicken
Meyer’s Famous Broasted Chicken
BBQ Chicken
-
Pork
Pork Tips and Noodles
Baked Pork Chops
Stuffed Pork Chop
Pork Chop Suey
Pork Goulash - Served over egg noodles
Oven Baked Ham
Center Cut Pork Loin
-
Beef
Steak Stroganoff
Beef Stew
Swiss Steak
Beef Tips over Egg Noodles
Salisbury Steak
-
Other Favorites
Shepherd’s Pie
Stuffed Peppers
Cabbage Rolls
-
Cold Sides
Pasta Salad
Potato Salad
Coleslaw
3 Bean Salad
All American Picnic $13
Includes our choice of (2) grilled favorites along with a condiment platter, (lettuce, tomato, onion, sliced American cheese, & pickles), homemade chips & dip, baked beans, potato salad & buns-
Choice of 2
Hotdogs
Hamburgers
Brats
Italians
Smoked Polish
Hungarian
Cheddarwurst + $2 per person
Turkey Burger + $2 per person
Veggie Burger + $2 per person
BBQ Picnic $16
Includes your choice of (2) backyard favorites, cowboy baked beans, chips and dip, Meyer’s homemade creamy coleslaw, Meyer’s famous potato salad, and Peter Sciortino’s buns-
Shredded and Pulled BBQ Chicken or Pork
-
BBQ Bacon Wrapped Meatloaf
-
BBQ Chicken
-
Wings
BBQ, Garlic Sesame, Buffalo, or Mango Habanero
-
BBQ Meaty Ribs
+ $2 per person
-
Slow Roasted Brisket
+ $2 per person
Papa Luigi Pizza Party $16
-
Fresh Garden Salad
-
Mama Maria’s Famous Garlic Bread
-
A Variety of Pizzas and Your Choice of Baked Mostaccioli or Garlic Butter Past
Quick Picks
-
Homestyle
Baked Chicken
Sliced Baked Ham
Mashed Potatoes and Gravy
Bread Dressing with Gravy
Sweet Corn
Creamy Coleslaw
Garden Salad
Bread and Butter
$15
-
The German
Sauerbraten
Pretzel Pork Cutlet
Spaetzle
Red Cabbage
Meyer’s Potato Salad
Rye Bread and Butter
$18
-
Southerner
Pulled Pork
Smoked Brisket
Famous Baked Beans
Creamy Coleslaw
Mac and Cheese
Cornbread Muffins and Honey Butter
$15
-
Taco Bar
Seasoned Ground Beef
Shredded Chicken
Rice and Beans
Tortillas
Chips and Salsa
Condiment Platter
$12
-
The Sicilian
Papa Luigi’s Lasagna
Chicken Cacciatore
Sicilian Veggies
Garlic Mashed Potatoes
Caesar Salad
Italian Bread and Butter
$15
-
Fat Tuesday
Jambalaya
Blackened Catfish
Red Beans and Rice with Andouille Sausage
Candied Sweet Potatoes
Meyer’s Creamy Coleslaw
$19
-
Fiesta
Bistec El Mexicana
Al Pastor
Rice and Beans
Corn and Flour Tortillas
Chips and Salsa
Condiment Platter
$19
Specialty Bars & Buffets
-
Potato Bar
Choose: Mashed or Baked
Choose 5 toppings: Cheddar cheese, bacon, grilled chicken breast, gravy, green onions, tomatoes, sautéed mushrooms and green peppers, corn, and broccoli
Includes: Sour cream, butter and a First Choice salad with dressings
$13.50
Add soup $3
-
Salad Bar
Fresh Romaine and Mixed Greens
Choose 5 toppings: Cheddar cheese, Feta cheese, bleu cheese crumbles, black olives, carrots, chopped hard boiled eggs, sliced red onion, mushrooms, broccoli florets, tomato, radish, pepperoncini and croutons
Choose 2 meats: Grilled chicken breast, chopped ham, roasted turkey breast, chicken salad or tuna salad
Includes: Assorted homemade dressings, Italian bread and butter, fresh fruit and pasta salad
$13.50
Add soup $3
-
Soup and Sandwich or Soup
You Pick 2
Choose any two of the following delicious options: One of our homemade soup options, a deli platter of breads, meats, cheese, and sandwich fixings, or our House Salad with assorted house-made dressings. Served with your choice of homemade chips or coleslaw, bread and butter, and oyster crackers$14
-
Street Taco Bar
Choose 2: Korean beef taco, pulled pork carnitas, fish tacos
Served with: Fresh cilantro, shredded lettuce, guacamole, tomato, onion, lime crema, Mexican rice, fresh fruit, corn and flour tortillas
$17
-
Make Your Own Fajitas
Tender grilled chicken and steak marinated and seasoned. Served with sautéed onions, red and green peppers, flour tortillas, refried beans, red rice, shredded cheese, jalapeno peppers, salsa, sour cream, homemade tortilla chips and churros
$15
Add guacamole or pico de gallo add $3
Desserts
Priced per person-
Schaum Torte
House-made, crispy meringue shell, filled, vanilla ice cream, strawberry topping, whipped cream
$3
-
Apple Strudel
$3
-
Lemon Berry Cake
$5
-
Chocolate Fudge Cake Sensation
$4
-
Apple Pie
$3
-
New York Cheesecake
$4
-
Carrot Cake
$3
-
Mini Cannoli
$3
-
Tiramisu
$4
-
Chocolate Chip Cookies
$2
-
Italian Cookies
$5
-
Dark Chocolate Brownie
$3
Bar & Beverage Services
-
Full Open Bar
For 1 hour service $14 per guest
Per bartender plus service charge $30 per hour
-
Beer, Wine, Water & Soda Bar
Per hour $8 per guest
Per bartender plus service charge $30 per hour
First Choice Catering
Corporate Meetings and Events Weddings • Rehearsal Dinners Showers • Anniversaries Reunions • Picnics Cocktail Parties Holiday Parties Tailgate Parties • Funerals Retirement Parties School Events Charity Events Fundraisers Contract Catering
Santa’s Elf Holiday
Appetizer PackageSelect any seven - $18.95 per guest
Additional selections - $2.00 per guest
Minimum 15 guests
-
Trio of Mini Sandwiches
Turkey breast, Black Forest ham, and tender roast beef on assorted mini rolls garnished with a pickle and black olive
-
Pigs in a Blanket
With honey mustard sauce
-
Cucumber Canapes
Sliced cucumber on cocktail rye with a dill sauce
-
Fiesta Dip and Chips
Layered Mexican dip and freshly made tortilla chips
-
Tater Kegs
Monster tots filled with bacon and cheddar cheese
-
Fresh Fruit Platter
An assortment of fresh seasonal fruit artfully displayed
-
Caprese Skewers
Fresh mozzarella balls, grape tomato, basil, balsamic glaze
-
Fresh Veggie Platter
Fresh seasonal veggies with ranch dip and roasted red pepper hummus
-
Classic Deviled Eggs
-
Buffalo Chicken Meatballs
Stuffed with bleu cheese and caramelized onion
-
Holiday Meatballs
Choose between our cranberry holiday BBQ sauce or classic Swedish
-
Wisconsin Cheese Platter
Assorted cubed Wisconsin cheeses with assorted crackers
-
Rumaki
Bacon-wrapped water chestnuts marinated in a teriyaki sauce and roasted
Mother Claus Holiday
Appetizer PackageChoose any seven - $20.95 per guest
Additional selections - $2.00 per guest
Minimum 15 guests
-
Warm Turkey Breast and Ham Sliders
Roasted turkey breast and sage gravy and hot Black Forest Ham on mini pretzel rolls with Dijon aioli
-
Or
-
Trio of Mini Sandwiches
Turkey breast, Black Forest Ham, and tender roast beef on assorted mini rolls garnished with pickle and black olive
-
Chimichurri Steak Phyllo Bites
Tender roast beef, arugula, gorgonzola, and chimichurri sauce in a phyllo cup
-
Fresh Fruit Kabobs
Fresh seasonal fruit on kabobs
-
Spinach and Artichoke Dip
With sliced baguettes and crackers
-
Roasted Grape Crostini
Roasted red grape on a toasted baguette with fresh thyme and ricotta
-
Fresh Veggie Platter
Fresh seasonal veggies with ranch dip and roasted red pepper hummus
-
Wisconsin Cheese and Sausage Platter
Wisconsin made assorted cheese and sausage beautifully arranged with assorted crackers
-
Mushroom Florentine Caps
Baked whole mushroom caps filled with spinach, parmesan, parsley, and breadcrumbs
-
Rumaki
Bacon-wrapped water chestnuts marinated in teriyaki and roasted
-
Cucumber Canapes
Sliced cucumber on cocktail rye with a dill sauce
Santa’s Holiday
Appetizer PackageChoose any seven - $24.95 per guest
Additional selections - $2.00 per guest
Minimum 15 guests
-
Cilantro Ginger Chicken Sliders
Chicken breast, mango salsa, and chipotle mayo on butter top roll
-
Sliced Tenderloin Slider
Beef tenderloin, arugula, artichoke horseradish aioli on a mini-brioche roll
-
Mini Beef Wellington
Beef tenderloin in a savory sauce of wine, mushrooms, and herbs, then wrapped in a flaky French pastry
-
Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail
Jumbo fresh shrimp, lemons, and cocktail sauce
-
Caprese Skewers
Fresh mozzarella balls, grape tomato, basil. And balsamic glaze
-
White Bean, Rosemary, and Garlic Crostini
Delicate combo of olive oil, a touch of garlic, cannellini beans, and chopped fresh rosemary
-
Asiago Arancini
Asiago, parmesan, and romano cheeses
-
Maryland Lump Crab Dip
With sliced baguettes and assorted crackers
-
Crudite Platter
Fresh green beans, asparagus, zucchini, radish, grape tomato, carrot, cauliflower, and broccoli with spinach artichoke dip and roasted red pepper hummus
-
Wisconsin Cheese and Sausage Platter
Wisconsin made an assortment of cheese and sausage beautifully arranged and served with an assortment of crackers
-
Fresh Fruit Display
With roasted and candied bacon
-
Italiano Mushroom Cap
Baked whole mushroom caps filled with mild Italian sausage, breadcrumbs, parmesan, chopped parsley, and cream cheese
-
Jalapeno Bacon Empanadas
Jalapeno, crispy bacon, cream cheese, cilantro, and scallion
Classic Holiday
Buffet$18.00 per guest
-
Salad
Holiday Tossed Salad - spring mix, tomato, red onion, carrot, cranberry vinaigrette
-
Entrees
Herb Roasted Whole Turkey Breast
Brown Sugar & Honey Glazed Pit Ham
-
Sides
-
Starches
Buttermilk mashed potatoes and gravy
Cornbread sage stuffing
-
Vegetables
Choose two
Honey and ginger glazed whole baby carrots
Roasted corn with red peppers and herbed butter
Green bean casserole
-
Dessert
Assortment of Christmas cookies
For pumpkin pie add $1.50 per person
-
Includes:
Rolls & Butter
Cranberry Sauce
Elegant Holiday
Buffet$20.00 per guest
-
Salad
Mixed Greens Salad - Mixed greens, fresh blueberries, candied walnuts, bleu cheese, balsamic vinaigrette
-
Entrees
Choose two
Roasted pork loin with apples - brined in herbs and roasted with fresh apples, apple cognac cream sauce
Holiday Roast - oven braised beef pot roast with bacon, onion, and apple juice
Herb Roasted Whole Turkey Breast
Brown Sugar & honey glazed pit ham
Chicken Marsala - pan fried boneless and skinless chicken breast in a Marsala wine sauce with mushrooms and onions
Baked Cod - cod fillet baked in a lemon butter and white wine sauce
Parmesan Crusted Chicken
Open Faced Pork Chops
Sides
-
Starches
Choose two
Herb roasted red potatoes
Roasted sweet potato cubes with ginger, maple syrup and butter
Garlic rosemary mashed potatoes
Festive Rice - rice pilaf with red pepper, onion, peas, and lemon zest
Bacon mac n cheese
-
Vegetables
Choose two
Green beans with mushrooms and bacon
Roasted baby carrots with cardamom and ginger
Corn Pudding
Roasted broccoli with garlic, lemon zest, lemon juice, and parmesan
Spicy candied yams with roasted walnuts
-
Dessert
Pumpkin and pecan pie with whipped cream
-
Includes:
Rolls & butter and Cranberry sauce
Prestige Holiday
Buffet$24.95 per guest
-
Salad
Apple Pecan Salad - Arugula, dried cranberries, roasted pecans, gala apples, feta cheese, with lemon vinaigrette
-
Entrees
Choose two
Red wine braised oh so tender short ribs (add 2.00/pp)
Roasted citrus salmon with braised fennel and dill
Pork Loin stuffed with herbs, apples, cranberries and walnuts
Holiday stuffed chicken breast - baked boneless and skinless with asiago, spinach, and asparagus
Beef Tenderloin - sliced beef tenderloin with Madeira mushroom sauce (add 4.00/pp)
Roasted bone-in chicken breast with brown butter, sage, and lemon
-
Sides
Choose two of each
-
Starches
Cranberry pecan wild rice pilaf
Roasted zucchini and carrots with rosemary, olive oil, pine nuts, and fontina
Twice baked potatoes with bacon
Garlic mashed potatoes with asiago cheese
Cauliflower mashed potatoes with garlic, scallions, butter, and parmesan
-
Vegetables
Roasted cauliflower with lemon - parsley dressing
Roasted root vegetables with fresh thyme
Tri-color baby carrots roasted with rosemary and spiced honey
Pan seared asparagus with balsamic drizzle
Caramelized brussel sprouts with bacon
-
Dessert
Choose one
Flourless Chocolate Cake topped with raspberry compote
Door County cherry cheesecake
-
Includes:
Assorted dinner rolls and butter
Cranberry sauce
Bar & Beverages
Packages-
Full Open Bar
For 3 hour service $15 per guest
Per bartender plus service charge $30 per hour
-
Beer, Wine, Water & Soda Bar
$12 per guest
Per bartender plus service charge $30 per hour
-
Non Alcoholic Beverages
Spiced Apple Cider
Hot Chocolate
Peppermint Cocoa
Classic Egg Nog
Holiday Punch
Cranberry Spritzer
-
Ask us about our holiday cocktails for your event!
Carved Stations
BuffetLet our event experts customize a gala holiday dinner with carving and other stations.
-
Main Entrée Carving Options
Prime Rib
Beef Tenderloin
Honey Baked Pit Ham
Roasted Whole Turkey Breast
Stuffed pork loin
-
Salad, Fruit, Cheese, and Veggie Station
-
Mashed and Baked Potato Station
-
Hot Vegetable Station
-
Dessert Station
Holiday Desserts
-
Pumpkin Pie with Whipped Cream
$2.75 per person
-
Pecan Pie with Whipped Cream
$3.25 per person
-
Flourless Chocolate Cake with Raspberry Compote
$4.25 per person
-
Assortment of Holiday Bars
$3.50 per person
-
Assortment of Christmas Cookies
$3 per person
-
Assortment of Holiday Petit Fours
$3.50 per person
-
New York Cheesecake
$4.25 per person
Call us today to discuss, plan, and quote your special holiday event! Reserve your date today, as our calendar fills fast!
Picnic & Tailgate Party
-
MEATS
Choose Three
Quarter pound all-beef hamburger
Grilled all-natural chicken breast
Johnsonville brat in beer
All-beef hot dog
BBQ pulled pork
Italian sausage with marinara and green peppers
-
Sides
Choose three
Good ole American potato salad
Italian pasta salad
Creamy coleslaw
Redskin potato salad
Savory mixed green salad
Fresh cut seasonal fruit
Fresh sliced watermelon
Cowboy baked beans
Grilled corn on a cob add $1.50
Mac n’ cheese add $1.50
-
Includes:
Our famous kettle chips
Fresh buns and condiments
Assorted cookies
Plate and paper service
-
(min. 100 guests) $14.25 per guest
(50-99 guests) $14.95 per guest
(25-49 guests) $15.95 per guest
Southern BBQ Picnic
-
Meats
-
Choose one
Texas BBQ braised beef brisket
Baby back ribs
-
Choose one
Marinated and grilled chicken pieces
BBQ pulled pork in tangy sauce
Quarter pound grilled all-beef hamburger
-
Sides
Choose three
Southern baked beans
Creamy coleslaw
Mac n Cheese
Sliced watermelon
Grandma’s potato salad
Bacon cheddar macaroni salad
Corn on a cob
Savory mixed greens salad
-
Includes:
Fresh buns
Our famous homemade kettle chips
Condiments
Assorted cookies
Plate and paper service
-
(min. 100 guests) $18.25 per guest
(50-99 guests) $19.50 per guest
(25-49 guests) $20 per guest
Olé Border Fiesta
-
Mains
choose three
Carne Asada Tacos - Grilled steak, Pico de Gallo, avocado, cilantro, queso fresco cheese, corn tortillas
Chicken Fajitas with onions, red and green peppers, sour cream, flour tortillas
Steak fajitas with onions, red and green peppers, sour cream, flour tortillas
Tacos al Pastor - Grilled marinated pork loin with pineapple, onion-cilantro relish, two chili salsa, lime, corn tortillas
Beef Tacos - ground beef, hard shell, lettuce, tomato, onion, cheddar cheese
Tamales - chicken, beef, pork, or cheese
Cheese Enchiladas
-
Sides
Choose three
Mexican grilled corn on cob
Frijoles charros (cooked pinto beans with bacon and chilies)
Red rice with cilantro and jalapenos
Mexican bean salad - corn, black beans, sweet peppers, cilantro, onion, limes, and spices
Refried beans
Mango with cilantro, coconut and chili powder
Papas con Rajas (sauteed potatoes and chilies with onion and cilantro)
Mexican salad with avocado yogurt dressing
-
Includes:
Fresh tortillas chips and salsa
Churros
Plate and paper service
-
(min. 100 guests) $17.95 per guest
(50-99 guests) $17.50 per guest
(25-49 guests) $18.95 per guest
Borderline Picnic
-
Mains
Choose three
Quarter pound grilled all-beef hamburger
Grilled all-natural chicken breast
Johnsonville brat in beer
Chili dogs
Chicken fajitas - with onion, red and green peppers, sour cream, flour tortillas
Steak fajitas - with onions, red and green peppers, sour cream, flour tortillas
Beef tacos - ground beef, hard shells, lettuce, tomato, onion, cheddar cheese
Cheese enchiladas
-
Sides
Choose three
Cowboy baked beans
Classic American Potato Salad
Italian Pasta Salad
Fresh sliced watermelon
Frijoles charros (cooked pinto beans with bacon and chiles)
Red rice with cilantro and jalapenos
Mexican bean salad (corn, black beans, sweet peppers, cilantro, onion, lime, and spices)
Papas con Rajas (sauteed potatoes and chilies with onion and cilantro)
-
Includes:
Our famous kettle chips
Fresh buns and condiments
Assorted cookies
Churros
All plate & paper service
-
(min. 100 guests) $15.95 per guest
(50-99 guests) $16.50 per guests
(25-49 guests) $16.95 per guest
The Ultimate Grill Out Party
-
Mains
-
Choose one
Prime rib
Grilled teriyaki shrimp
-
Choose one
Grilled pork tenderloin
Grilled tropical chicken breast
Grilled boneless pork chop
-
Sides
Choose three
Mixed green salad
Baked potato with sour cream and chives
Roasted red skin potatoes with peppers
Roasted fingerling potato salad
Pasta salad
Fresh seasonal fruit salad
Sauteed green beans with onion and mushrooms
Corn on the cob
-
Includes:
Our famous kettle chips
Rolls with butter
Strawberry shortcake dessert
Condiments
All plate and paper service
-
(min. 100 guests) $29.95 per guest
(50-99 guests) $30.50 per guest
(25-49 guests) $30.95 per guest
We cater to all occasions!
Corporate Meetings & Events • Weddings Rehearsal Dinners • Showers • Anniversaries Reunions • Picnic • Cocktail Parties Holiday Parties • Tailgate Parties • Funerals Retirement Parties • School Events Charity Events • Fundraisers Contract Catering
First Choice Catering is a full-service catering company dedicated to providing you and your guests with the best experience. The Purpora family, owners of Meyers Restaurant and Papa Luigi’s, have been serving the community for over 45 years, known for serving deliciously crafted meals and exceptional service at an affordable price.
First Choice Catering has an extensive menu to accommodate all events, large or small. We have a reputable history in the corporate world offering box lunches, buffet lines, individually packaged meals, and catering to both picnics and holiday parties.
We offer a wide variety of wedding packages to accommodate you on your special day. We are extremely proud of our creative chefs, team, and staff for their outstanding care for our customers. The Purpora family is excited to be apart of your next event and can’t wait to show you why we’re the First Choice.
Appetizer Packages
Must be accompanied by a meal.-
Package One
Choose any four
Cheese and crackers
Fresh vegetable platter
Fresh fruit platter
Bruschetta
Mini BBQ meatballs
Liver pate
$7 per guest
-
Package Two
Choose any four
Can include options from package oneCaprese skewers
Seafood stuffed mushrooms
Buffalo wings
Chicken tenders
Mediterranean hummus
Reuben dip
Mac & cheese bites
$8 per guest
-
Package Three
Choose any four
Can include options from package one or twoJumbo shrimp cocktail
Chips and dip (Choice of artichoke dip, dill dip, french onion dip, beer cheese dip, reuben dip, or buffalo chicken dip)
Smoked salmon
Italian sausage and peppers
Bacon wrapped water chestnuts
Korean pork sliders
-
Package Four
Choose any four
Can include options from packages one, two, or threeCharcuterie board
Antipasto plates
Crab cakes
Seafood empanadas
Arancini (rice balls)
Boneless buffalo wings
$14.50 per guest
Buffet Selections
Please inquire if you would like additional selections for your menu.Additional carved meat + $6 per person
Additional Entrée + $4 per person
-
The Original
(2) Entrée Choices
(1) Specialty Side
(1) Potato
(1) Fresh Vegetable
(1) Buffet Salad
Dinner Rolls
$25 per guest
-
The Standard
Carved Pork Loin
(1) Additional Entrée
(1) Specialty Side
(1) Potato
(1) Fresh Vegetable
(1) Buffet Salad
Dinner Rolls
$29 per guest
-
The Premiere
Carved Turkey Breast
(1) Additional Entrée
(1) Specialty Side
(1) Potato
(1) Fresh Vegetable
(1) Buffet Salad
Dinner Rolls
$33 per guest
-
The Deluxe
Carved Beef Sirloin
(2) Additional Entrées
(1) Specialty Side
(1) Potato
(1) Fresh Vegetable
(1) Buffet Salad
Dinner Rolls
$38 per guest
-
The Ultimate
Carved Beef Tenderloin or Choice Angus Prime Rib
(2) Additional Entrées
(1) Specialty Side
(1) Potato
(1) Fresh Vegetable
(1) Buffet Salad
Dinner Rolls
$45 per guest
Buffet Entrée Choices
Please inquire if you would like additional selections for your menu.
Chicken
-
Chicken Parmigiana
Italian breaded chicken breast, pan-fried and topped with marinara, mozzarella, and parmesan cheese
-
Baked Chicken Cacciatore
Boneless, skinless chicken breast slow-cooked in a tasty red sauce with yellow and red peppers, sliced mushrooms, tomatoes, and herbs
-
Oven Roasted Chicken
Skin-on chicken pieces rubbed with olive oil and spices, then baked with fresh rosemary until golden brown
-
Parmesan Crusted Chicken
Boneless, skinless chicken breast topped with parmesan cream, toasted bread crumbs, and broiled
-
Chicken Caprese
Natural chicken breast grilled and topped with fresh basil, Roma tomatoes, and fresh mozzarella cheese
-
Chicken Marsala
Pan-fried chicken breast in a dry Marsala wine sauce with mushrooms and onions
-
Chicken Piccata
Parmesan bread crumbs, white wine and lemon sauce, capers
-
Fettuccine Alfredo with Grilled Chicken
Homemade creamy alfredo
Beef & Pork
-
Braised Short Rib Ragu
-
Barbecue Ribs
Slow-cooked pork ribs, so tender, in Chef Gil’s homemade BBQ sauce
-
Beef Spiedini
Thinly sliced beef marinated in olive oil, hand-rolled and stuffed with Sicilian bread crumbs, topped with sautéed mushrooms and onions
-
Sliced Ham
Smoked pit ham baked and served with a pineapple glaze
-
Open Faced Stuffed Pork Chops
-
Sliced Pork Loin
Thyme and rosemary crusted loin
-
Pulled Pork
Slow-cooked pork shoulder, pulled and shredded, Chef Gil’s homemade BBQ sauce
Seafood
-
Crab Linguine Alfredo
Linguine pasta, crab pieces, and creamy homemade alfredo sauce
-
Sicilian Shrimp Scampi
Sautéed shrimp in a garlic/butter/fresh parsley and white wine sauce
-
Bourbon Salmon
Atlantic salmon let, brushed with homemade bourbon glaze, then broiled
-
Baked Cod
Tender let, Spanish paprika, and baked in a wine butter
Additional Selections
-
Specialty Sides
Cowboy Baked Beans
Homemade Mac and Cheese
Pasta with Garlic Butter
Pasta with Marinara
Italian Pasta Salad
Roman Potato Salad
Meyer’s Famous Potato Salad
Asian Slaw (Soy Sauce, Teriyaki, Sesame Oil, Rice Vinegar, Shredded Red and Green Bell Peppers, Cabbage and Carrots.)
Bok Choy Salad (Ramen Noodles, Sliced Almonds, Shredded Bok Choy, Vinegar and Oil.)
-
Starches
Roasted Fingerling Potatoes
Roasted Red Potatoes
Parsley Boiled Potatoes
Garlic Mashed Potatoes
Baked Potatoes
Cheesy Hash Brown Potato Bake
-
Fresh Vegetables
Bourbon Glazed Carrots
Roasted Asparagus
Roasted Brussel Sprouts
Green Beans Almondine
Blend of Vegetables
Steamed Broccoli with Hollandaise or Cheese Sauce
Oven Roasted Cauliower
Sweet Buttered Corn
Corn on the Cob
-
Buffet Salads
Garden Salad
Caesar Salad
Antipasto Salad + $2
Waldorf Salad + $1
Cobb Salad + $1
Apple Pecan Arugula Salad + $1
Strawberry Gorgonzola + $1
Additional Hors D’oeuvres
Priced per person-
Crab Cakes
$6
-
Chicken Tenders
$3
-
Boneless Wings
$4
-
Wonton Wrapped Mozzarella Sticks
$4
-
Reuben Rolls
$4
-
Seafood Stuffed Mushrooms
$4
-
Seafood Empanadas
$5
-
Smoked Salmon
$5
-
Liver Pate
$4
-
Sliced Italian Sausage with Peppers
$3
-
Meatballs
Choice of Italian, Swiss, BBQ, or German
$3
-
Toasted Bruschetta
$3
-
Caprese Salad
$4
-
Mediterranean Hummus Platter
$4
-
Chips and Dip
Choice of Artichoke Dip, Dill, French Onion, Beer and Cheese, Rueben Dip and Buffalo Chicken Dip
$5
-
Bacon Wrapped Water Chestnuts
$4
-
Shrimp Cocktail
$7
-
Korean Pork Sliders
$4
-
Roll Ups
Choice of Vegetable, Ham, or Turkey
$3
-
Assorted Silver Dollar Sandwiches
$4
-
Fruit Platters
$3
-
Vegetable Platters
$3
-
Cheese and Cracker Plates
$4
-
Charcuterie Boards
$7
-
Antipasto Plate
$7
Desserts
Priced per person-
Schaum Torte’s
House-made, crispy meringue shell, lled, vanilla ice cream, strawberry topping, whipped cream
$3
-
Apple Strudel
$3
-
Lemon Berry Cake
$5
-
Chocolate Fudge Cake Sensation
$4
-
Apple Pie
$3
-
New York Cheesecake
$4
-
Carrot Cake
$3
-
Mini Cannoli
$3
-
Tiramisu
$4
-
Chocolate Chip Cookies
$2
-
Italian Cookies
$5
-
Dark Chocolate Brownie
$3
Service Packages
-
Classic Buffet
Entrée Served Buffet Style
Wire Chaffing Racks
Tables Bussed by First Choice Staff
Upscale Disposable Plates
Reflections Disposable Silverware
2 ply Dinner Napkin
$4.50 per guest
-
Graceful Buffet
Entrée Served Buffet Style
Formal Silver Chafers
Tables Bussed by First Choice Staff
Full China Package (dinner plate, salad plate, dessert plate, water glass, silverware)
Elaborate Preset Table (silverware, glass, water pitchers, salt/pepper caddy, napkin, salad & dressing)
$7.50 per guest
-
Established Buffet
Meal Served Family Style to Table on Platters
Tables Bussed by First Choice Staff
Full China Package (dinner plate, salad plate, dessert plate, water glass, silverware)
Elaborate Preset Table (silverware, glass, water pitchers, salt/pepper caddy, napkin, salad & dressing)
$9.95 per guest
-
Timeless Buffet
Butler Passed Appetizers
Plated and Served Salads
Plated and Served Entrée
Preset Rolls And Butter Pads on Bread and Butter Plate
Preset Salad Dressings in China Bowls
Full China Package (dinner plate, salad plate, dessert plate, water glass, silverware)
Elaborate Preset Table (silverware, glass, water pitchers, salt/pepper caddie, napkin, salad & dressing)
Water Placed on Table
$14.95 per guest
Bar & Beverage Packages
-
Full Open Bar
For 1 hour service $14 per guest
Per bartender plus service charge $30 per hour
-
Beer, Wine, Water & Soda Bar
Per hour $8 per guest
Per bartender plus service charge $30 per hour
-
Non Alcoholic Beverages
Spiced Apple Cider
Hot Chocolate
Peppermint Cocoa
Classic Eggnog
Holiday Punch
Cranberry Spritzer
Ask us about our holiday cocktails for your event!
CONDITIONS
PRICING – Prices and menus subject to change at any time unless under contract.
QUALITY – We promise to use only quality products and ingredients and to hire quality employees.
SERVICE – Providing quality food is fruitless without providing excellent, above, and beyond service. We pride ourselves on our ability to listen to our customers and be adapt-able to meet their peculiar needs with enthusiasm and a smile. We treat everyone like they are a part of our family.
EVENT PLANNING AND SALES – Our knowledgeable staff will assist you in the planning and execution of your event from A to Z. Please allow us to be your one-stop and take care of all your event and catering needs. Call our office between 8 am and 4 pm, Monday – Friday. We are always available by appointment to meet your schedule.
PORTIONS – It is our intent to provide you and your guests with an adequate amount of all foods based on our 25 years in the catering business. Please let us know in advance if you feel your event will require more than average consumption.
DIETARY NEEDS – Please let us know in advance of any special dietary needs for you or any of your guests. We have options available for any dietary restrictions/ requirements.
GUEST COUNTS – Final guest counts are due 30 days before the event date. After that, we will accommodate increases, but due to commitments in scheduling, food, and equipment, we cannot decrease.
CANCELLATIONS – Things happen. Cancellations must be called into our office as soon as possible and confirmed by email. Refunds will be made on an individual basis with regard given to mitigating damages.
DEPOSITS – Deposits are required for all special events and weddings to ensure service, staff, and equipment for that chosen date. The final payment is due two weeks before the event by check or credit card.
SPECIAL PLANNING – Weddings and large special events require much more time than calculated in our menu pricing. A 22% service charge will be added for these events.