4260 S 76th St, Greenfield, WI 53220 (414) 321-4400
4260 S 76th St, Greenfield, WI 53220 (414) 321-4400
Main content starts here, tab to start navigating

Everyday Catering

First Choice Catering is a full-service catering company dedicated to providing you and your guests with the best experience. The Purpora family, owners of Meyers Restaurant and Papa Luigi’s, have been serving the community for over 45 years, known for serving deliciously crafted meals and exceptional service at an affordable price. 

First Choice Catering has an extensive menu to accommodate all events, large or small. We have a reputable history in the corporate world offering box lunches, buffet lines, individually packaged meals, and catering to both picnics and holiday parties. 

We offer a wide variety of wedding packages to accommodate you on your special day. We are extremely proud of our creative chefs, team, and staff for their outstanding care for our customers. The Purpora family is excited to be apart of your next event and can’t wait to show you why we’re the First Choice.

Breakfast

  • Breakfast Box

    Grab and Go! Choice of Bagel with cream cheese or breakfast muffin, fresh cut-up fruit, and yogurt with granola

    $9

  • Farmers market Breakfast Casserole

    Italian Chicken Sausage, onion, sliced mushrooms shredded hash browns, cheddar cheese, green peppers, tomatoes, and eggs baked till golden brown. Served with fresh fruit, bagels, and muffins

    $12.95

  • Baked Oatmeal

    Rolled oats with dried cranberries & spiced apples, baked & topped with a vanilla cream sauce served with fresh fruit salad and assorted muffins

    $9

  • Spinach and Ham Gruyere Frittata

    Delicate baked egg frittata with fresh spinach, black forest ham, and rich Gruyere cheese

    $12.50

  • Good Morning

    Scrambled Eggs, Bacon, Pork or Turkey Sausage, Potatoes O’ Brian, Bagels, Muffins, and Seasonal Fruit

    $11.95

  • Build Your Own Breakfast Burrito

    Scrambled eggs, green pepper, tomato, onion, blended cheese, cilantro, and choice of chorizo, sausage, or bacon. Served with Flour tortilla, salsa, fresh fruit, and hashbrowns or Potatoes O’ Brian

    $11.50

  • Continental

    An assortment of fresh donuts, Danish, bagels, muffins, and seasonal fruit. Served with cream cheese, jam, and butter

    $9.95

  • Country Breakfast

    Scrambled Eggs, biscuits and sausage gravy, bacon, and seasonal fruit

    $11.95

  • Homemade Pancakes

    Served with Bacon, Pork, or Turkey Sausage (choice of 2 options per event)

    Buttermilk Pancakes $10.50

    Chocolate Chip Pancakes $11

    Blueberry $11

    Granny Smith Apple $11.50

    Cherry Cobbler $11.50

    Red Velvet $11.50

    Cinnamon Roll $11.50

  • Home Style Corned Beef Hash

    Served with scrambled eggs, fresh fruit salad, and assorted muffins

    $12.95

Appetizer Platters

Small - Serves up to 15 guests
Medium - Serves up to 25 guests
Large - Serves up to 35 guests

  • Smoked Salmon Platter

    Norwegian style smoked Atlantic salmon thinly sliced and beautifully displayed with boiled colored baby potatoes, red onion, sliced cucumbers, sliced radish, sliced cherry tomato, hardboiled egg, caper guests, lemon wedges, fresh dill, cream cheese and rye cocktail bread

    Small $69.95

    Medium $94.95

    Large $124.95

  • Street Skewers

    An assortment of skewers fashioned off street vendors: beef bulgogi, lemongrass pork, and chicken satay

    Small $59.95

    Medium $79.95

    Large $99.95

  • Vegetarian Platter

    An inviting platter of vegetarian bites including: roasted vegetable skewers; mini cucumber, cream cheese, avocado, and sprout wraps; asparagus and caramelized onion tartlets; Caprese skewers – cherry tomato, fresh mozzarella, and fresh basil

    Small $59.95

    Medium $79.95

    Large $99.95

  • Get Pickled and Go Nuts Platter

    An enticing display of pickled vegetables, spiced nuts, and Wisconsin cheese curds

    Small $64.95

    Medium $84.95

    Large $104.95

  • Salsa Trio

    Your guests will say ‘ole to our homemade guacamole, Pico de Gallo and black bean corn salsa served with seasoned homemade tortilla chips

    Small $49.95

    Medium $59.95

    Large $79.95

  • Chips and Dips

    Homemade spinach and sour cream dip, roasted red pepper hummus paired with homemade pita chips, and our famous homemade kettle chips

    Small $49.95

    Medium $59.95

    Large $79.95

  • Vegetable Crudité

    Seasonal garden vegetables served with organic dill dip and red pepper hummus

    Small $42.95

    Medium $59.95

    Large $77.95

  • Hummus Trio

    Classic, harissa red pepper and basil pesto hummus served with pita bread, pita chips, cucumbers, bell peppers, and grape tomatoes

    Small $49.95

    Medium $69.95

    Large $89.95

  • Fresh Fruit

    Fresh seasonal fruit

    Small $54.95

    Medium $72.95

    Large $94.95

  • Wisconsin Cheese Tray

    An assortment of Wisconsin cheese selections served with an assortment of crackers, grapes, and candied nuts

    Small $53.95

    Medium $72.95

    Large $90.95

  • Cheese and Sausage Tray

    Our Wisconsin cheese offerings served with a variety of local sausages and crackers

    Small $69.95

    Medium $88.95

    Large $107.95

  • Artisan Cheese Platter

    An inspiring display of aged cheddar, Havarti, Manchego, and Bleu cheese accompanied with baguette, crackers, dried fruit, nuts, and preserves

    Small $81.95

    Medium $101.95

    Large $121.95

  • Italian Platter

    Mini roasted vegetable and fresh pesto skewers; little salami, cherry mozzarella, artichoke, and tomato spikes with an herb dip; lemon and rosemary marinated chicken skewers with olive tapenade dip

    Small $69.95

    Medium $89.95

    Large $107.95

  • Mini Sandwich Platter

    An assortment of sandwiches on mini-rolls that includes: curried chicken salad; roasted turkey breast with cranberry mayo; tomato, mozzarella, and basil with balsamic mayo; tender roast beef and cheddar with Dijon mayo

    $36 per dozen

  • Mini Wrap Platter

    Selection of mini wraps with following fillings; pesto mayo, grilled chicken with spinach; roasted vegetables with mozzarella; bacon, butternut and feta; shaved roast beef with romaine, tomato, and lemon Dijon mayo

    $36 per dozen

  • Wraps and Minis

    Selection of our most popular artisanal wraps and sandwiches on mini rolls, and assorted wraps

    $36 per dozen

Cold Hors d’Oeuvres

  • Smoked Salmon Rye Canape

    Goat cheese, thin slices of smoked salmon, shaved radish, and a watercress sprig on top of cocktail rye bread

    24 pieces $54.95

  • Prosciutto Wrapped Mozzarella and Basil

    Cherry tomato, mozzarella ball, and basil wrapped in prosciutto and drizzled with balsamic glaze

    24 pieces $54.95

  • BLT Crostini

    Toasted baguette topped with herb mayo, lettuce, tomato, and applewood bacon

    24 pieces $42.95

  • Caprese Skewers

    Cherry tomatoes, fresh mozzarella ovoline, and basil drizzled with a balsamic reduction

    24 pieces $42.95

  • Antipasto Skewers

    Provolone, salami, cherry tomato and pepperoncini

    24 pieces $44.95

  • Fresh Fruit Kabobs

    Cut fresh seasonal fruit on a skewer

    24 pieces $38.95

  • Cucumber Canapés

    Classic finger sandwich on rye with herbed cream cheese and mayo, fresh cucumber and topped with diced pimento and dill

    24 pieces $40.95

  • Prosciutto Wrapped Asparagus

    Asparagus spears wrapped in prosciutto drizzled lemon-infused extra virgin olive oil and dusted with aged parmesan cheese

    24 pieces $49.95

  • Chicken Avocado Bacon Slider

    Pepper jack cheese, avocado spread with cilantro, bacon, grilled chicken breast, tomato, caramelized onion, and a wee bit of hot sauce on a slider bun

    24 pieces $69.95

  • Shrimp Cocktail

    Jumbo steamed shrimp with classic cocktail sauce and lemon

    24 pieces $59.95

  • Ricotta & Black Olive Crostini

    With lemon zest and mint. Amazing combination

    24 pieces $42.95

  • Bistro Beef Bites

    Deli roast beef on snack rye with horseradish cream spread topped with a half grape tomato and sour cream

    24 pieces $59.95

  • Tomato Bruschetta

    An Italian classic, toasted baguette slices topped with fresh diced, onion, garlic, olive oil, and fresh basil

    24 pieces $42.95

  • Deviled Eggs

    Classic deviled eggs with horseradish, vinegar, mayo, and smoked paprika

    24 pieces $34.95

  • Sriracha Deviled Eggs with Bacon

    Live a little!

    24 pieces $36.95

Hot Hors d’Oeuvres

  • Angus Cheddar Sliders

    Angus slider with cheddar cheese and condiments

    24 pieces $79.95

  • Buffalo Chicken Slider

    Chicken breast fritter in Buffalo sauce on a mini roll with lettuce and bleu cheese dressing

    24 pieces $69.95

  • Mini Street Taco Quesadilla

    Shredded chicken, shredded Mexican cheese, jalapeno, pico de gallo, cilantro, red onion, and spices in a grilled flour tortilla. Olé!

    24 pieces $49.95

  • Teriyaki Chicken Skewer

    Grilled teriyaki marinated chicken breast cubes on a skewer

    24 pieces $45.95

  • Grilled Asian Steak Kabob

    Cubes of sirloin marinated in a delicious Asian sesame sauce grilled with red onion and pineapple

    24 pieces $69.95

  • Mini Meatball Skewer

    Beef and pork mini meatballs on a spike with marinara or BBQ sauce

    24 pieces $39.95

  • Jalapeno Popper

    Our homemade jalapeno pepper stuffed with pineapple and cream cheese, wrapped in bacon and baked. Can you eat just one?

    24 pieces $44.95

  • Mini Chicken Cordon Bleu

    Mini chicken cordon bleus with Swiss cheese and smoked ham, coated in bread crumbs and baked

    24 pieces $48.95

  • Mini Beef Wellington

    Beef tenderloin simmered in a savory sauce of wine, mushrooms, and herbs, then wrapped in a flaky French pastry

    24 pieces $79.95

  • Spinach Artichoke Cup

    Won’t last long! Spinach, artichoke, parmesan cheese, mozzarella cheese, cream cheese, sour cream, and a touch of cayenne mixed and baked in a phyllo cup

    24 pieces $55.95

  • Buffalo Wings

    Our breaded and deep-fried wings. Choose between buffalo, sesame ginger, or honey soy sauce. Served with celery and bleu cheese dip

    24 pieces $49.95

  • Rumaki

    Bacon-wrapped chestnuts with soy glaze

    24 pieces $39.95

  • Sausage Stuffed Mushroom Caps

    Large mushroom caps generously stuffed with a spicy Italian sausage stuffing

    24 pieces $49.95

  • Spinach & Cheese Stuffed Mushrooms

    Mushroom caps stuffed with feta, spinach, and cream cheese then dusted with bread crumbs

    24 pieces $45.95

  • Vegetable Spring Roll

    A colorful mixture of Chinese vegetables tossed with soy sauce, sesame oil, and a touch of fresh ginger wrapped in a spring roll wrapper. Served with sweet and sour sauce

    24 pieces $39.95

  • Crab Cakes

    Full-sized crab cakes topped with lemon mustard and tarragon aioli. Served with remoulade sauce

    24 pieces $69.95

  • Meatballs

    Cocktail meatballs in your choice of Swedish or our homemade BBQ sauce

    24 pieces $34.95

  • Potato Skins

    Baked half potato skin filled with avocado, bacon, cheddar and topped with a dollop of sour cream and chopped chives

    24 pieces $49.95

  • Mini Quiche

    An assortment of three cheese, mushroom, classic French and Florentine

    24 pieces $49.95

  • Italian Beef Bites

    Thinly sliced Italian beef with mozzarella and hot giardiniera wrapped up in a crispy wonton wrapper served with au jus

    24 pieces $39.95

  • Rueben Rolls

    Chopped corned beef hand-rolled with swiss cheese and sauerkraut in a crispy wonton wrapper. Served with house-made thousand island dressing

    24 pieces $39.95

  • Italian Sausage

    With peppers and onions

    24 links sliced $59.95

Cold Buffets

Deli Wrap and Sandwich Buffet $13

Your choice of any four of the following along with two sides and our homemade chips

  • Roasted Turkey Breast Pesto Sandwich

    Swiss Cheese, red onion, pesto, lettuce, and tomato on focaccia bread

  • Loaded Steer

    Tender sliced roast beef, creamy horseradish mayo, sliced tomato, cheddar cheese, pickled red onion, and arugula in a whole wheat wrap

  • Turkey Avocado Club Sandwich

    Roast Turkey breast, avocado, romaine lettuce, red onion, cucumber applewood smoked bacon on focaccia bread

  • Homemade Chicken or Tuna Salad

  • Chicken Caesar Wrap

    Romaine, tomato, grilled chicken breast, Caesar dressing in a tomato basil wrap

  • Ham and Cheese on Rye

    Black forest ham, Swiss cheese, lettuce, tomato, and Dijon on rye bread

  • Portabella

    Grilled portabella cap topped with red onions, tomatoes, cucumbers, spinach, roasted red peppers, and pesto cream cheese on a focaccia bread

Deli Boards $12

Your Choice of three meats and two cheeses
Served with homemade chips, two side salads, assorted rolls and breads, lettuce, tomatoes, red onion, pepperoncini, pickles mustard and mayo

  • Meats:

    Roast beef, turkey breast, shaved ham, homemade shaved corned beef, chicken salad, and tuna salad

  • Cheese:

    Wisconsin Cheddar, Swiss, Pepper Jack

  • Side Choices:

    Potato salad, creamy coleslaw, pasta salad, fresh fruit, Asian slaw, mixed green salad

Box Lunches $11

Includes, one sandwich with chips, one side, pickle, and cookie

  • Sandwich Options:

    Sliced Ham

    Sliced Turkey Breast

    Shaved Roast Beef

    Chicken Salad

    Tuna Salad

  • Side Options:

    Potato Salad

    Fresh Fruit

    Creamy Coleslaw

    Asian Slaw

    Pasta Salad

    Mixed Green Salad

Artisanal Sandwiches & Wraps Box Lunch $13

One premium wrap or sandwich, one side, dill pickle, chips, and a freshly baked cookie

  • Little Italy

    Ham, Salami, Pepperoni, olive oil, red wine vinegar, oregano, hot peppers, lettuce, tomato, wrapped in a tomato basil wrap served on focaccia bread

  • Portabella

    Grilled portabella cap topped with red onions, tomatoes, cucumbers, spinach, roasted red peppers, and pesto cream cheese on a focaccia bread

  • Chicken or Tuna Salad Croissants

  • Loaded Steer

    Tender sliced roast beef, creamy horseradish mayo, sliced tomato, cheddar cheese, pickled red onion, and arugula in a whole wheat wrap

  • Chicken Caesar Wrap

    Romaine, tomato, grilled chicken breast, Caesar dressing in a tomato basil wrap

  • Turkey Avocado Club Sandwich

    Roast turkey breast, avocado, romaine lettuce, red onion, cucumber applewood smoked bacon served on focaccia bread

Salad Boxes

Include Italian bread and butter and a cookie

  • Chicken Caesar

    Grilled chicken breast on a bed of romaine lettuce, tossed with black olives, diced tomatoes, shredded parmesan cheese, croutons, served with homemade Caesar dressing

    $10

  • Chicken BLT Salad

    Grilled chicken breast on a bed of crisp iceberg lettuce, tossed bacon, hard-boiled eggs, onions, tomatoes, black olives, and avocado, served with crumbled bleu cheese and choice of dressing

    $11

  • Chef Salad

    Sliced ham and turkey on a bed of crisp iceberg lettuce, tossed with hard-boiled eggs, onions, tomatoes, peppers, and cheese

    $12

  • Fiesta Chicken

    Crispy fried chicken breast on a bed of fresh greens with onion, pepper, tomato, shredded cheddar jack cheese blend, and black olives served in a crispy tortilla shell, with salsa and sour cream

    $12

  • Hot Bacon Cobb

    Grilled chicken breast on a bed of fresh baby spinach with red onion, tomato, mushroom, boiled egg, swiss cheese, and our house-made hot bacon dressing

    $12

  • Harvest Cobb

    Chargrilled chicken breast over romaine with chopped eggs, dried cranberries, fresh apples, blue cheese crumbles, applewood smoked bacon, pecans, and peas and finished with a homemade poppy seed vinaigrette

    $12

  • Waldorf

    Chargrilled chicken breast tossed with crispy green apples, grapes, roasted walnuts, and celery served with a homemade Waldorf dressing

    $12

  • Apple Pecan Arugula

    Chargrilled chicken breast tossed with dried cranberries, roasted pecans, gala apples, feta cheese, and arugula, finished with a homemade lemon vinaigrette

    $12

  • Summer Berry Salad

    Grilled chicken breast atop crispy lettuce, tomatoes, blueberries, strawberries, raspberries, blackberries, toasted almonds, mandarin oranges, cucumbers, feta cheese, and a homemade raspberry walnut vinaigrette

    $12

  • House Salad

    $9.25

Hot Buffets

Grand Buffet

All entrées include your choice of our house salad or Caesar salad and fresh dinner rolls
One entrée, one starch, one vegetable from our tasty options below | $16
Two entrées, a vegetable, and two sides | $18

  • Lasagna

    Featuring Papa Luigi’s Homemade Favorite! Fresh pasta layered with seasoned ground beef, ricotta, mozzarella, and parmesan cheese, topped with Papa Luigi’s signature marinara

  • Papa Luigi’s Fettuccine Chicken Alfredo

  • Chicken Piccata

    Tender chicken breast, breaded and sautéed in white wine, lemon butter caper enhanced sauce

  • Classic Beef Stroganoff

    Tender beef tips sautéed with mushrooms and onions and simmered in a rich sour cream and burgundy sauce. Served with egg noodles

  • Slow Cooked Pot Roast

    Boneless sliced short rib slow-cooked with peas, carrots, onions, and mashed potatoes, topped with a rich homemade gravy

  • Beef Tips Bourguignonne

    Tender tips of beef, seared and served in a red wine and demi-glaze sauce

  • Eggplant Parmesan

    Thinly sliced eggplant, breaded in egg wash and seasoned breadcrumbs, fried then layered with Papa Luigi’s marinara, mozzarella, and baked

  • Mom’s Meatloaf

    Pan-seared homemade meatloaf, topped with homemade rosemary mushroom gravy

  • Roast Turkey dinner

    Slow-roasted turkey with sage and herbs

  • Roasted Chicken

    Skin-on chicken pieces rubbed with olive oil and spices, then baked with fresh rosemary until golden brown

  • Honey Baked Ham

    Smoked pit ham and served with a pineapple glaze

  • Herb Crusted Pork Loin

    Thyme and rosemary crusted loin

  • Starches

    Rice pilaf, Classic garlic mashed potatoes, Baked potato with sour cream & butter, Oven-roasted rosemary potatoes, Mac n’ cheese, Butter garlic pasta

  • Vegetables

    Honey glazed carrots, Green beans Amandine, Garlic parmesan roasted broccoli, Tuscan sautéed vegetables – yellow squash, zucchini, carrots, green beans, red pepper, Whole kernel corn, basil and red pepper medley, Steamed California vegetables – broccoli, cauliflower, and carrots

Executive Buffet

All entrées include your choice of our house salad or Caesar salad and fresh dinner rolls
One entrée, one starch, one vegetable from our tasty options below | $18
Two entrées, a vegetable, and two sides | $20

  • Slow Roasted Beef Brisket

    Moist and tender slow-roasted brisket served in a horseradish thyme cream sauce

  • Spinach and Artichoke Stuffed Chicken Breast

    Baked all-natural chicken breast stuffed with spinach, artichoke, cream cheese, mozzarella, and herbs

  • Cherry Stuffed Pork Loin

    Slow-roasted pork loin stuffed with cherries, onion, celery, carrot, parsley, sage, rosemary, and croutons. Served with a rosemary gravy

  • Braised Cabernet Short Ribs

    Short ribs braised and slow-cooked for 5 hours until fork-tender

    Add $2

  • Chicken Marsala

    Pan-fried chicken breast in a dry marsala wine sauce with mushrooms & onions

  • Chicken Cordon Bleu

    Large boneless chicken breast stuffed with smoked ham and swiss cheese and then lightly breaded and baked

  • Bourbon Glazed Salmon

    Atlantic salmon filet, brushed with homemade Bourbon glaze, then baked

  • Butternut Squash Ravioli

    In a sage brown butter sauce

  • Goat Cheese Ravioli

    Fluffy pillows of pasta filled with creamy goat cheese in a rich champagne sauce

  • Parmesan Crusted Chicken

    Boneless skinless chicken breast topped with a parmesan cream sauce, toasted bread crumbs, and broiled

  • Starches

    Roasted cauliflower puree with parmesan and crispy onions Long grain wild rice, Whipped potatoes with parmesan or gorgonzola Roasted root vegetables, Bacon quinoa with almonds and herbs Double baked potato, Fingerling roasted potatoes, Mushroom risotto

  • Vegetables

    Garlic parmesan roasted broccoli, Peas with onion, mushrooms and tarragon Sautéed zucchini and squash with garlic and parmesan Braised Brussels sprouts in cider and bacon Parisian carrots, Pan seared asparagus Green beans with cherries and citrus glaze ...more Hot Buets

Italian Buffet $18

Includes 2 entrees, one starch, a salad and bread & butter

  • Pasta Entrées

    Pasta with Meatballs

    Fettuccini Alfredo - Choose Chicken or Shrimp

    Lasagna - Choose Meat or Spinach

    Cheese or Beef Tortellini

    Lasagna Rolls - Choose 4 Cheese, Italian Sausage or Spinach

    Pasta Primavera

    Italian Macaroni & Cheese

    Crab Linguine Alfredo

    Sal’s Seafood Sensation - Linguini pasta with sautéed shrimp, lobster, scallops, crab meat & garlic butter

  • Sausage

    Italian Sausage & Peppers

    Sausage Cacciatore

  • Veal

    Veal Piccata + $2

    Veal Parmigiana + $3

  • Chicken

    Chicken Parmigiana

    Baked Chicken Cacciatore

    Oven Roasted Chicken

    Parmesan Crusted Chicken

    Chicken Caprese

    Chicken Marsala

    Chicken Piccata

  • Beef

    Hand Rolled Spiedini

    Sliced Italian Beef

  • Beef Upgrades

    + $3

    Sicilian Steak

    Steak Marsala

    Braised Short Rib

    Short Rib Ragu

  • Choice 2 Potatoes or 2 Pastas

    Pasta with Marinara, Garlic Butter, Alfredo or Champagne Sauce

    Roasted Fingerling Potatoes

    Roasted Baby Reds

    Parsley Boiled Potatoes

    Garlic Mashed Potatoes

    Sicilian Potato Salad

Themed Packages

American Comfort Food $18

Two entrées served with a garden salad, sage bread dressing, mashed potatoes and gravy, a vegetable and choice of cold side

  • Poultry

    Roasted Turkey Breast

    Roasted Chicken

    Meyer’s Famous Broasted Chicken

    BBQ Chicken

  • Pork

    Pork Tips and Noodles

    Baked Pork Chops

    Stuffed Pork Chop

    Pork Chop Suey

    Pork Goulash - Served over egg noodles

    Oven Baked Ham

    Center Cut Pork Loin

  • Beef

    Steak Stroganoff

    Beef Stew

    Swiss Steak

    Beef Tips over Egg Noodles

    Salisbury Steak

  • Other Favorites

    Shepherd’s Pie

    Stuffed Peppers

    Cabbage Rolls

  • Cold Sides

    Pasta Salad

    Potato Salad

    Coleslaw

    3 Bean Salad

All American Picnic $13

Includes our choice of (2) grilled favorites along with a condiment platter, (lettuce, tomato, onion, sliced American cheese, & pickles), homemade chips & dip, baked beans, potato salad & buns

  • Choice of 2

    Hotdogs

    Hamburgers

    Brats

    Italians

    Smoked Polish

    Hungarian

    Cheddarwurst + $2 per person

    Turkey Burger + $2 per person

    Veggie Burger + $2 per person

BBQ Picnic $16

Includes your choice of (2) backyard favorites, cowboy baked beans, chips and dip, Meyer’s homemade creamy coleslaw, Meyer’s famous potato salad, and Peter Sciortino’s buns

  • Shredded and Pulled BBQ Chicken or Pork

  • BBQ Bacon Wrapped Meatloaf

  • BBQ Chicken

  • Wings

    BBQ, Garlic Sesame, Buffalo, or Mango Habanero

  • BBQ Meaty Ribs

    + $2 per person

  • Slow Roasted Brisket

    + $2 per person

Papa Luigi Pizza Party $16

  • Fresh Garden Salad

  • Mama Maria’s Famous Garlic Bread

  • A Variety of Pizzas and Your Choice of Baked Mostaccioli or Garlic Butter Past

Quick Picks

  • Homestyle

    Baked Chicken

    Sliced Baked Ham

    Mashed Potatoes and Gravy

    Bread Dressing with Gravy

    Sweet Corn

    Creamy Coleslaw

    Garden Salad

    Bread and Butter

    $15

  • The German

    Sauerbraten

    Pretzel Pork Cutlet

    Spaetzle

    Red Cabbage

    Meyer’s Potato Salad

    Rye Bread and Butter

    $18

  • Southerner

    Pulled Pork

    Smoked Brisket

    Famous Baked Beans

    Creamy Coleslaw

    Mac and Cheese

    Cornbread Muffins and Honey Butter

    $15

  • Taco Bar

    Seasoned Ground Beef

    Shredded Chicken

    Rice and Beans

    Tortillas

    Chips and Salsa

    Condiment Platter

    $12

  • The Sicilian

    Papa Luigi’s Lasagna

    Chicken Cacciatore

    Sicilian Veggies

    Garlic Mashed Potatoes

    Caesar Salad

    Italian Bread and Butter

    $15

  • Fat Tuesday

    Jambalaya

    Blackened Catfish

    Red Beans and Rice with Andouille Sausage

    Candied Sweet Potatoes

    Meyer’s Creamy Coleslaw

    $19

  • Fiesta

    Bistec El Mexicana

    Al Pastor

    Rice and Beans

    Corn and Flour Tortillas

    Chips and Salsa

    Condiment Platter

    $19

Specialty Bars & Buffets

  • Potato Bar

    Choose: Mashed or Baked

    Choose 5 toppings: Cheddar cheese, bacon, grilled chicken breast, gravy, green onions, tomatoes, sautéed mushrooms and green peppers, corn, and broccoli

    Includes: Sour cream, butter and a First Choice salad with dressings

    $13.50

    Add soup $3

  • Salad Bar

    Fresh Romaine and Mixed Greens

    Choose 5 toppings: Cheddar cheese, Feta cheese, bleu cheese crumbles, black olives, carrots, chopped hard boiled eggs, sliced red onion, mushrooms, broccoli florets, tomato, radish, pepperoncini and croutons

    Choose 2 meats: Grilled chicken breast, chopped ham, roasted turkey breast, chicken salad or tuna salad

    Includes: Assorted homemade dressings, Italian bread and butter, fresh fruit and pasta salad

    $13.50

    Add soup $3

  • Soup and Sandwich or Soup

    You Pick 2
    Choose any two of the following delicious options: One of our homemade soup options, a deli platter of breads, meats, cheese, and sandwich fixings, or our House Salad with assorted house-made dressings. Served with your choice of homemade chips or coleslaw, bread and butter, and oyster crackers

    $14

  • Street Taco Bar

    Choose 2: Korean beef taco, pulled pork carnitas, fish tacos

    Served with: Fresh cilantro, shredded lettuce, guacamole, tomato, onion, lime crema, Mexican rice, fresh fruit, corn and flour tortillas

    $17

  • Make Your Own Fajitas

    Tender grilled chicken and steak marinated and seasoned. Served with sautéed onions, red and green peppers, flour tortillas, refried beans, red rice, shredded cheese, jalapeno peppers, salsa, sour cream, homemade tortilla chips and churros

    $15

    Add guacamole or pico de gallo add $3

Desserts

Priced per person

  • Schaum Torte

    House-made, crispy meringue shell, filled, vanilla ice cream, strawberry topping, whipped cream

    $3

  • Apple Strudel

    $3

  • Lemon Berry Cake

    $5

  • Chocolate Fudge Cake Sensation

    $4

  • Apple Pie

    $3

  • New York Cheesecake

    $4

  • Carrot Cake

    $3

  • Mini Cannoli

    $3

  • Tiramisu

    $4

  • Chocolate Chip Cookies

    $2

  • Italian Cookies

    $5

  • Dark Chocolate Brownie

    $3

Bar & Beverage Services

  • Full Open Bar

    For 1 hour service $14 per guest

    Per bartender plus service charge $30 per hour

  • Beer, Wine, Water & Soda Bar

    Per hour $8 per guest

    Per bartender plus service charge $30 per hour

First Choice Catering

Corporate Meetings and Events Weddings • Rehearsal Dinners Showers • Anniversaries Reunions • Picnics Cocktail Parties Holiday Parties Tailgate Parties • Funerals Retirement Parties School Events Charity Events Fundraisers Contract Catering

Email Signup

Please check errors in the form above
Thank you for signing up for email updates!
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.